Title: RCM 706 Emails

Release Date: 2014-03-20

Text: UNITEDSTATESOF AMERICAManning, Bradley E.PFC, U.S. Army,HHC, U.S. Army Garrison,Joint Base Myer-Henderson HallFort Myer, Virginia 22211Prosecution Response toDefense Motion to Dismissfor Lack of Speedy TrialEnclosure 77 (RCM 706 Emails)23 October 2012OATETIMEUnclassified_Email_RCM_706_00013-Aug-lOUnclassified Email RCM 706 0002Unclassified Email RCM 706 00034-Aug-lO4-Aug-lO11:06:0012:11:44Unclassified Email RCM 706 00045-Aug-lO14:24:25Unclassified Email RCM 706 00056-Aug-lO15:04:48Unclassified Email RCM 706 00068-Aug-lO20:53:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_000710-Aug-lO10:06:52Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_000810-Aug-lO10:59:55Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_000912-Aug-lO20:11:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_001023-Aug-lO14:54:00Unclassified Email RCM 706 0011Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_001223-Aug-lO15:27:4025-Aug-lO10:27:13Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0013Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_001425-Aug-lO10:53:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_001526-Aug-lO26-Aug-lO07:06:2407:25:24Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_001626-Aug-lO08:33:34Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_001726-Aug-lO11:43:42Unclassified Email RCM 706 001826-Aug-lO11:55:01Unclassified Email RCM 706 001926-Aug-lO12:03:09Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0020Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_002126-Aug-lO1-Sep-lO1-Sep-lO1-Sep-lO6-Sep-lO12:22:1711:14:23Email NumberUnclassified_Email_RCM_706_0022Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0023Unclassified Email RCM 706 0024Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0025Unclassified Email RCM 706 00266-Sep-lO12:15:0011:44:2612:06:0023:50:0023:50:5412:57:57Unclassified Email RCM 706 00279-Sep-lO9-Sep-lO13:01:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_00289-Sep-lO15:37:45Unclassified Email RCM 706 00299-Sep-lO21:14:00Unclassified Email RCM 706 0030lO-Sep-lO08:30:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0031lO-Sep-lO10:01:11Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0032lO-Sep-lO10:04:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0033Unclassified Email RCM 706 003417-Sep-lO07:08:0017-Sep-lO09:44:30Unclassified Email RCM 706 003520-Sep-lO12:02:00Unclassified Email RCM 706 003620-Sep-lO14:08:59Unclassified Email RCM 706 003720-Sep-lO14:19:02Unclassified Email RCM 706 003822-Sep-lO16:07:35Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_003922-Sep-lOUnclassified Email RCM 706 004023-Sep-lO16:11:0012:57:21Unclassified Email RCM 706 004123-Sep-lO14:24:24Unclassified Email RCM 706 004214-Oct-lO22:01:00Unclassified Email RCM 706 004315-Oct-lO08:11:05Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_00444-Nov-lO09:11:00Unclassified Email RCM 706 00454-Nov-lO13:11:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_00464-Nov-lO16:36:44Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_004713-Dec-lO15:11:18Unclassified Email RCM 706 004820-Dec-lO18:59:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0049Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_005021-Dec-lO21-Dec-lO07:42:0807:59:44Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_005121-Dec-lO09:52:57Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_005221-Dec-lO10:12:32Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_005321-Dec-lO10:17:50Unclassified Email RCM 706 005421-Dec-lO12:10:16Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_005529-Dec-lO12:10:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_005629-Dec-lO12-Jan-ll12:11:25Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0057Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_005813-Jan-ll12:32:0009:45:44Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_005919-Jan-ll13:19:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_006021-Jan-ll10:17:26Unclassified Email RCM 706 006121-Jan-ll10:39:00Unclassified Email RCM 706 006221-Jan-ll11:13:00Unclasslfied_Email_RCM_706_0063Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_006421-Jan-ll21-Jan-ll11:18:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_006521-Jan-ll13:09:46Unclassified Email RCM 706 0066Unclasslfled_Email_RCM_706_006721-Jan-ll21-Jan-ll21-Jan-ll13:37:4913:40:0513:56:52Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0069Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0070Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_007121-Jan-ll22-Jan-ll18:42:0012:27:4922-Jan-ll12:29:00Unclassified Email RCM 706 0072Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_007322-Jan-ll22-Jan-ll12:31:0012:34:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_007422-Jan-ll12:34:00Unclassified Email RCM 706 007526-Jan-ll08:47:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_007626-Jan-ll17:48:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_007726-Jan-ll17:49:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_007826-Jan-ll18:27:00Unclassified Email RCM 706 007927-Jan-ll07:19:08Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_006813:01:50Unclassified Email RCM 706 008027-Jan-ll07:41:29Unclassified Email RCM 706 008127-Jan-ll07:57:46Unclassified Email RCM 706 008227-Jan-llUnclassified_Email_RCM_706_008327-Jan-ll09:03:1515:44:57Unclassified Email RCM 706 008427-Jan-ll15:55:54Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_008527-Jan-ll16:20:09Unclassified Email RCM 706 008627-Jan-ll17:46:26Unclassified Email RCM 706 0087Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_00883-Feb-ll4-Feb-ll19:41:0007:41:47Unclassified Email RCM 706 0089Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_00904-Feb-ll4-Feb-ll08:00:0008:30:12Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0091Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_00927-Feb-ll08:46:037-Feb-ll08:49:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_00937-Feb-ll14:37:55Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_00947-Feb-ll15:12:45Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_00957-Feb-ll15:53:38Unclassified Email RCM 706 0096Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_00977-Feb-ll15:59:197-Feb-ll17:52:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0098Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_00997-Feb-ll18:07:00Unclassified Email RCM 706 01008-Feb-ll8-Feb-ll07:48:3513:53:02Unclassified Email RCM 706 0101Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01028-Feb-ll8-Feb-ll23:26:0023:27:38Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01039-Feb-ll05:16:36Unclassified Email RCM 706 01049-Feb-ll06:48:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01059-Feb-ll07:51:54Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_010611-Feb-ll06:43:25Unclassified Email RCM 706 010711-Feb-ll06:49:50Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_010814-Feb-ll08:03:19Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_010914-Feb-ll08:13:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0110Unclasslfied_Emall_RCM_706_011114-Feb-ll15-Feb-ll2-Mar-ll08:44:4211:57:052-Mar-ll23:17:11Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0112Unclassified Email RCM 706 0113Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_011423:14:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0115Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0116Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01172-Mar-ll3-Mar-ll23:18:0013:23:113-Mar-ll3-Mar-ll13:33:5813:36:33Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01183-Mar-ll13:58:20Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01193-Mar-ll14:07:48Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01203-Mar-ll15:32:01Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01213-Mar-ll22:12:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01223-Mar-ll22:59:09Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01237-Mar-ll14:24:32Unclassified Email RCM 706 01247-Mar-ll15:20:39Unclassified Email RCM 706 01257-Mar-ll15:34:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0126Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01278-Mar-ll9-Mar-ll23:04:39Unclassified Email RCM 706 01289-Mar-ll16:30:52Unclassified Email RCM 706 012911-Mar-ll08:44:04Unclassified Email RCM 706 013014-Mar-ll07:45:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_013114-Mar-ll07:49:47Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_013214-Mar-ll08:47:00Unclassified Email RCM 706 0133Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_013414-Mar-ll14-Mar-ll09:52:37Unclassified Email RCM 706 013514-Mar-ll10:54:00Unclassified Email RCM 706 0136Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_013714-Mar-ll13:23:3914-Mar-ll14:34:47Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_013814-Mar-ll14:50:35Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_013914-Mar-ll15:22:20Unclassified Email RCM 706 0140U nclassified_Ema il_RCM_706_014115-Mar-ll16:07:0017-Mar-ll07:56:00U nclassified_Ema il_RCM_706_014217-Mar-ll20-Mar-ll07:57:1321-Mar-ll08:22:40Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_014521-Mar-ll08:23:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_014622-Mar-ll12:35:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_014723-Mar-ll15:35:27Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_014823-Mar-ll16:51:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_014924-Mar-ll14:45:40Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_015024-Mar-ll15:03:00Unclassified Email RCM 706 015124-Mar-ll15:08:24Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_015225-Mar-ll11:45:35Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0153Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0154Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0155Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_015628-Mar-ll21:38:0028-Mar-ll30-Mar-ll30-Mar-ll22:02:2810:02:3212:39:23Unclassified Email RCM 706 0157Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_015830-Mar-ll31-Mar-ll12:42:2215:32:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0159l-Apr-lll-Apr-ll09:26:23Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0143Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0144Unclassified Email RCM 706 016016:29:0010:34:0200:52:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01612-Apr-ll11:10:1010:27:41Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01628-Apr-ll07:07:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01638-Apr-ll13:14:01Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01648-Apr-ll14:12:24Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01658-Apr-ll14:59:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01668-Apr-ll15:50:06Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_016715-Apr-ll07:58:00Unclassified Email RCM 706 016815-Apr-ll07:59:37Unclassified Email RCM 706 016915-Apr-ll09:07:55Unclassified Email RCM 706 017015-Apr-ll09:20:36Unclassified Email RCM 706 017115-Apr-ll09:42:33Unclassified Email RCM 706 017215-Apr-ll09:59:31Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_017315-Apr-ll17:30:00Unclassified Email RCM 706 017415-Apr-ll17:31:07Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0175Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_017615-Apr-ll16-Apr-ll17:31:0908:31:01Unclassified Email RCM 706 017719-Apr-ll17:03:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_017819-Apr-ll17:04:52Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_017919-Apr-llUnclassified_Email_RCM_706_018022-Apr-ll17:05:0009:39:07Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_018122-Apr-ll09:40:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_018222-Apr-ll09:48:49Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_018322-Apr-ll09:50:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_018422-Apr-ll09:52:34Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_018522-Apr-ll09:55:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_0186Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_018722-Apr-ll09:56:1522-Apr-ll14:35:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01883-Aug-ll17:30:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01894-Aug-ll13:04:28Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01904-Aug-ll13:31:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01914-Aug-ll14:11:43Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01924-Aug-ll14:49:16Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_01934-Aug-ll14:54:00Unclassified_Email_RCM_706_019422-Aug-ll18:25:00Unclassified Email RCM 706 019522-Aug-ll20:07:0002872814From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:Attachments:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJATuesday, August 03, 2010 11 ;07 AMMICHAEL.SWEDA@US.ARMY.MIL(b) (6): Rose, Luke CPT USD-C SJA Chief Military JusticeRCM 706 Order (PFC Manning)Charge Sheet (ManningB).pdf; RCM 706 Order (ManningB).pdfImportance:HighSir,Good morning. Attached is a RCM 706 Board Order for PFC Bradley Manning. Attached is theorder and a copy of the charge sheet. CCed on this email are the defense counsel (CPTBouchard, CPT Eaton, and MAJ Hurley). Please advise of any delays and i f your office needsadditional time than the allotted suspense, please forward the request through me for theConvening Authority.v/rCPT FeinAshden FeinCPT, 3AChief, Military JusticeU.S. Army Military District of Washington (MDW)(b) (6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0001FOR OFFICIAL USEONLY02221964From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYSweda, Michad G Dr CIV USA MEDCOM WRAMC>Wednesday, August 4, 2010 12:10 PMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA Hurley, Thomas F MAJ MIL USA OTJAG (b) (6)il>;(b) (6); Eaton, Michael L CPT USF-I SJ A Trial DefenseAttomey (b) (6)RE: RCM 706 Order (PFC Manning) (UNCLASSIFIED)(b) (6)Classificauon; UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NONESn:Will the sanity board members require an) level of security clearancefortius?v/r.Micliael Sweda, Ph.D.. ABPP (Forensic)Board-Certified Forensic Psv chologistChieL Forensic Psv chologv ServiceDirector, Forensic Psvchologv Fellowsliip WalterReed Amiy Medical Center(b) (6)"The Umted States themselves arc essentially the greatest poem.Past and present and future are not disjoined but joined."FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02872799From:Sent:To:OcSubject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJAWednesday, August 04, 2010 12:15 PMSweda, Michael G Dr CIV USA MEDCOM WRAMCHurley, Thomas F MAJ MIL USA OTJAG;(b) (6)L CPT USF-I SJ A Trial Defense Attorney; l(b) (6)CPT MIL USARE: RCM 706 Order (PFC Manning) (UNCLASSIFIED)Eaton, Michael; Morrow, JoDeanSir,I do not foresee the need; however I rather defer that answer to MA] Hurley and the defenseteam. There is one caveat. A current protective order is in place and i t does not authorizethe disclosure of any of the classified information related to this case without affirmativeauthorization. So i f there ends up being a need, although doubtful, then the Government w i l lneed to work to get an exception to the protective order.v/rCPT FeinAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. Army Military District of Washington (MDW)(b) (6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0003FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02216961FOROFFICIALUSEONLYllHurley,ThomasFMAJ MIL USA OTJAG l(b) (6)Thursday,Augusf 05, 20102:24 PMFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQNCR/MDW SJA; Sweda,MichadGOrCIV^USA MEDCOMWF^MC(b) (6); Eaton,MichaelLCPT USFlSJATrial DefenseAttorney; (b) (6);Morrow,JoDean CPT MIL USARE: RCM 706 Order (PFC Manning) (UNCLASSIFIEO)From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:Signed 8y:(b) (6)Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NO^EDr. Sweda/CPT FeinThere is no need for the members of the board to have a security clearance.I w i l l speak with PFC Manning tomorrow about the board and ensure that hisanswers to your questions do not include any classified information. I f hefeels he must disclose classified information, then he w i l l let you knowthat there is more that he wants to say but cannot. CPT Fein and I w i l lthen seek an exception to the current order.v/rThomas F. HurleyMAJ, JA(b) (6))Unclassified^EmaiLRCM^706^0004FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221960FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYSweda, Michad G Dr CIV USA MEDCOM WRAMCFrom:(b) (6)Sent:To:Friday, August 6, 2010 3:04 PMHurley, Thomas F MAJ MIL USA OTJAG (b) (6)il>;>Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)(b) (6); Eaton, Michael L CPT USF-1 SJ A Trial DefenseAttomey (b) (6)Morrow,JoDean CPT MIL USA (b) (6); Lange, Christopher L LTCMIL USA MEDCOM WRAMC (b) (6)>; Montalbano, PaulDr CIV USA (b) (6)Mdone, Ricky D COL MIL USAMEDCOM WRAMC (b) (6)>RE; RCM 706 Order (PFC Manning) (UNCLASSIFIED)Cc:Subject:Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NONECPT Fein;I Iiave consdted vviUi LTC Cliristopher Lange. w ho is an counterpart asDirector of the Forensic Psycliiatrv Fellowship, regarding the Manningcase. We are in the process of assembling a team for the evaluation,and expect tlie direct evaluation piece (inten lew and testing) of tliislo be completed in two weeks. Generally, vve ask for at least a six weeksuspense date for completion of a 706 report. In the case of PFCManning, we wodd like to request a tliree month suspense from the datedial he is first seen, to allow for a dto rough e\ alualion.Pleiise feel free to call or e-mail if you Iiave any questions.v/r.Michael Sweda, Ph D . ABPP (Forensic)Board-Certified Forensic Psv cliologisiChief. Forensic Ps>"chologv Sen iceDirector, Forensic Psvchologv Fellowsliip Walter Reed Annv Medical Center(b) (6)The United States themselves arc essentially llie greatest poem.Past and present and fulure arc not disjoined but joined."FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02872810From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJASunday,August 08.20108:54 PMSweda,MichadGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMC: Huriey, ThomasFMAJ MIL USAOTJAG(b) (6)l; Eaton,MichaelLCPT USFlSJATrial OefenseAttorney:(b) (6);Morrow,JoOean CPT MIL USA; Lange,ChrisfopherLLTC MIL USA MEOCOM WRAMC: Montalbano Pad Oi^Ciy^ USA; Malone, RickyOCOLMIL USA MEDCOM WRAMC: Haberiand, John CPT MIL USARE: RCM 706 Otder (PFC Manning) (UNCLASSIFIEO)5ir,Thank you. The United States and the Oefense counsel w i l l discuss yout^ request with eachothet^ oyer the next few days. We w i l l likely have more questions of you before taking thisrequest to the Convening Authority.v/rCPTFeinAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. ArmyMilitary District of Washington (MDW)(b) (6)UnclassifiedEmailRCM 706 0006FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02216953From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:Signed 8y:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYHuriey,ThomasFMAJ MIL USA OTJAG ( (b) (6)llTuesday.Augusf 10,2010 10:07 AMbSweda,MichadGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMC)Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQNCR/MOW( SJA: Bouchard,PadRCPT USOCOSTBBCOTOS SrDefense Counsel; Eaton,MichaelLCPTUSFlSJATrial Oefense Attorney6)RE: RCM 706Order(PFC Manning) (UNCLASSIFIEO)(b) (6)Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NONEDr. SwedaI am one of PFC Manning's defense counsel. I know we a l l (the attorneys f o rboth parties) appreciate your prompt attention t o this matter, and I knowthat we a l l want a thorough evaluation of PFC Manning that follows the ordersigned by COL Coffman on 3 August. However, we (the defense) would be muchmore comfortable with an i n i t i a l six week suspense. I f , at the end of thatsix weeks, you need more time to complete a thorough evaluation, then wewould request that you forward a request f o r an extension that estimates thetime required t o complete the process.PFC Manning i s i n p r e - t r i a l confinement, and we want to get his casereferred to t r i a l sooner rather than later.On a substantive note, we believe the order signed by COL Coffman i ssufficient for the chat^ges now pr^efet^t^ed. Thet^e ane no others additionalquestions we want you t o answer i n the course of completing this matter.Thanks.v/rThomas F. HurleyMAJ, JA(b) (6)FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221954From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYSweda, Michael G Dr CIV USA MEDCOM WRAMC(b) (6)Tuesday, August 10, 2010 11 00 .AMHurley, Thomas F MAJ MIL USA OTJAG (b) (6)>(b)(6)Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJAil>;(b) (6); Eaton, Michael L CPT USF-I SJ A Trial Defense(Attomey (b) (6); Lange, Christopher L LTC MIL USAb(b)(6)MEDCOM WRAMC>; Benesh, Samantha M CPT)MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC ; Hemphill, Maria R(6LTC MIL USA MEDCOM BAMC ;Fdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b)(6)>Matthew kemkes (b) (6)(b) (6); Eaton, Michael L CPT USF-1 SJ A Trial DefenseAttomey (b) (6)Morrow III, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQNCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)RE: RCM 706 (PFC Manning) (UNCLASSIFIED)ClassincaUon: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NONEALCON;We are scheduled to begin our ev alualion of PFC Mamiing this Friday 27August, but have norecordsother tliaa tlic 706 order and cliarge slieet.We ordinarily ask for: mental healthrecords(including inpatientstays, if am ), medical records (noit .AHLTA. if any. as AHLTA can beeasily viewed on line), witness statements, areportofinvestigation(to the extent that is available giv en the pre-ArticIc 32 standing oftlie case, or a summaiy of invesugation to date), witness statements,militaiy employmentrecords,and any otlvcrrelevantdocuments.Please indicate what will be made av ailable and when.Records may be sent by FedEx or similar couner to;Dr. Michael SwedaChief Walter Reed Forensic Psv chology Serv iceWaller Reed .Annv Medical Center6900 Georgia Av enue NWBldg 6 (Borden Pavilion), Psychology Dept. 3rd FloorWasliington DC 20307v/r.Michael Sweda. Ph D,. ABPP (Forensic)Board-Certified Forensic PsychologistChief Forensic Psv chologj Serv iceDirector. Forensic Psvchology Fellowsliip WalterReed Annv Medical Center(b) (6)(b) (6)The Umted States themselves arc essentially the greatest poem.Past and present and future arc not disjoined bul joined."FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02215940From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:Attach:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYcoombs@armycourtraartialdefense.comWednesday, August 25, 2010 10:27 AMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)Matthew kemkes CPT Fein,I have been retained by PFC Manning to represent him in his case. I will be making my representation ofhim public early next w/eek. Please forward the attached request to the convening authority priorto having the R.C.M. 706 board begin its work. Additionally, please ensure that Dr. Sweda and the boardhave all ofthe requested documentation before beginning their work. This would prevent the necessity ofrequesting that the military judge reopen the R.C.M. 706 board at a later date.If you have any questions or concerns, feel free to contact me.Best,DavidDavid E. Coombs, Esq.Law Office of David E. Coombs45 North Main StreeL 5th FloorFall River, MA 02720Direct Dial: (401) 744-3007Office: (508) 674-6006Fax: (508) 324-9896mP.mbs#armym.w.A.m.art;iai(j@f^www.armycourtmartialdefense.com***Confidentiality Notice: This transmission, including attachments, may contain confidential attorneyclient information and is intended for the person(s) or company named. If you are not the intendedrecipient, please notify the sender and delete all copies. Unauthorized disclosure, copying or use ofthisinformation may be unlawful and is prohibited.***FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02879505Prom:S^nt:T^:^:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJAWednesday,August25, 201010:53 AMcoombs@armycourimartialdefense.coraMaffhev^kemkes; Paul Bouchard; Michad Eaton;(b) (6);Monov^ III,JoOean,CPT USAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA; Haberiand,John CPT MIL USA;Rose, Luke CPT USO-C SJA Chief Military JusticeRE: Oefense Experi Requesf-706 BoardMr. Coombs Acknowledged,immediately.The United States w i l l process the defense requestOr. Sweda- The prosecution w i l l present the delay request to the conveningauthority i n the next 24 hours (assuming he i s available) and have an answeron whether the RCM 706 8oard i s delayed or not.v/rCPT FeinAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. A r m y M i l i t a r y D i s t r i c t ofWashington (MOW)(b) (6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0013FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221950From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY(b) (6)Thursday, .August 26, 2010 7:06 AMl>;Fdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)Matthew kemkes (b) (6)>(b) (6); Eaton, Michael L CPT USF-1 SJ A Trial DefenseAttomey (b) (6); Morrow III, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQNCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)RE: RCM 706 (PFC Manning) (UNCLASSIFIED)Classincation: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NONEALCON;We vvill meet tomorrow (27 Aug) w iili PFC Mamiing lo begin our evaluationTlius far. we have no documentation bul can begin w ith certain aspects ofdie evaluation ev en in absence of tliisI wanted to double check to coiifinn tliat there arc no security issuesabout our interview, and llial we can handle notes in tlie usual manner.Michael SwedaCliieL WRAMCC Forensic Psv chologv Serv ice(b) (6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0014FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02215931FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYBouchard, Paul R CPT USD-C DSTB B CO TDS Sr Defense CounselFrom:(b) (6)Sent:To:Cc:Thursday. August 26, 2010 7:22 AMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)>(b)(6)Matthew kemkes>; Eaton, Michael L. CPT USD-C(b)(6)SJA/ATOS Officer(b) (6); 'coombs(^annycourtmartialdefense.com'RE: Defense Expert Request - 706 BoardManning - Expert RequesLpdfSubject:Attacb:Dr. Sweda:Ilie lead attomey for PFC Manning is Mr, David Coombs (His e-mail address is on the cc line, and please read the below e-mail).Yesterday, the Defenserespectfullyrequested that an additional doctor - one on the defaise team - be appointed for purposes ofthe706. (Sec e-mail attaclimcnl).Moreover, given recent discussions with our client, vve now have security concems as they pertain to the 706.With that, werequestthat the 706 be pushed back until these issues/requests are resolvedRespectfully,CPT BouchardCPT Paul BouchardSenior Defense CounselCamp Liberty. Iraq(b) (6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0015FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02872828FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYFrom:Sent:To:Cc:Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MOW SJAThursday, August 26, 2010 8:34 AM(b) (6); Matthew kemkes(b) (6)Eaton, Michael L CPT USF-I SJ A Trial DefenseAttomey; Morrow III, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA;(b) (6)Subject:Re: RCM 706 (PFC Manning) (UNCLASSIFIEO)Dr. Sweda. As of l a t e l a s t n i g h t , the convening a u t h o r i t y granted the defense delay u n t i l theGCMCA takes action on the expert request. The formal documentation w i l l be sent l a t e r t h i smorning, ^ r . CPT FeinAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, M i l i t a r y Justice(b) (6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0016FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221947From:Sent:To:Cc:FOROFFICIALUSEONLY(b) (6)Thursday,Augusf26, 201011:44 AMFein, Ashden CPTUSAJFHQNCR/^fDW SJA (b) (6)l>;>Matthew kemkes (b) (6)(b) (6); Eaton, MichaelLCPTUSF-I SJATrial Defi^nse>; Morrow III, JoDean, CPT USA JEHQAttorney (b) (6)NCR (b) (6)lSubject:RE:RCM 706(PFCManning)(UNCLASSlF1ED)ClassificationUNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NONESir:Ijust wanted to make sure Ihatlam tmcking on this Tliis means iliatwewill need toresdieduleour first evaluation sessionforalaterdale7v/r,Michael Sweda. Ph D ABPP (Forensic)Boaid-Ccrtified Forensic PsychologistChief. Forensic Psy chology Serv iceDirector. Forensic Psv chology Fellow ship Waller Reed Amiv Medical Center(b) (6)'^TheUnited States themselves are essentially tlie greatest poem.Pastand present and fnture are not disjoined but joined"Unclassified Email RCM 706 0017FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02872825FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYFrom:Sent:To:Cc:Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJAThursday, August 26, 2010 11:55 AM(b) (6)L; Matthew kemkes(b) (6)'; Eaton, Michael L CPT USF-I SJ A Trial DefenseAttorney; Morrow III, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MOW SJA; (b) (6)Subject:Re: RCM 706 (PFC Manning) (UNCLASSIFIED)Dr. Sweda. Yes, please reschedule and please wait t o reschedule u n t i l we get back t o you i nthe near f u t u r e , ^ r . CPT FeinAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, M i l i t a r y Justice(b) (6)Unclassified_Email RCM 706 0018FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221943From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY(b) (6)Thursday, August 26, 2010 12:03 PMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)il>;Matthew kemkes (b) (6)(b) (6)Eaton, Michael L CPT USF-I SJ A Trial DefenseAttomey (b) (6)Morrow III, JoDean, CPT USA JEHQNCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)RE: RCM 706 (PFC Manning) (UNCLASSIFIED)Classification; UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats; NONECPTFein;No problem. We will wait until we haveagofroinyou to rcsdiedtile.v/^Michael Sweda,PliD ABPP (Forensic)Board-Certified Forensic Psy chologistChieL Forensic Psy cliology Serv iceDirector. Forensic Psv chologv Fellow ship Walter Reed Amiv Medical Center(b) (6)"The United Slaleslhemselves are essentially the greatest poem.P^ist and present and future arc not disjoined bul joined "FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02206252From:Sent:To:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYMorrow IILJoDean, CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA(b) (6)Thursday,Augusf26,20lO 12:22PM(b) (6)SJA (b) (6)(b) (6)Cc:L;Fein,AshdenCPTUSAJEHQNCR/MDWMatthew kemkesEaton,MichaelLCPT USFlSJATrial DefenseAttorney,02869028FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFrom:Sent:To:Subject:Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJAFriday,Sepfember10, 2010 10:04 AM(b) (6); Morrow III,JoDean, CPTUSA JFHQNCR/MOW SJARE: USvManning (UNCLASSIFIEO)Thank you s i r .Ashden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. Army Military D i s t r i c t of Washington (MDW)(b) (6)FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02878564From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJAFriday,September 17,2010 7:08 AM(b) (6)Morrow III,JoDean,CPT USAJFHQNCR/MDW SJAExpert Consultant (Manning)Sir. Good morning. I know you and Joe have been chatting about the expert consultant forPFC Manning. I was wondering i f you have had any luck with determining i f he is the rightpersoni^ We were hoping to have the convening authority appoint the person NLT today becausethe request is now 3 weeks old. Thank you very much.v/rAshdenAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. ArmyMilitary District ofWashington (MOW)(b) (6)UnclassifiedEmailRCM 706 0033FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221935FOROFFICIAL USE ONLYFrom:Sent:To:Subject:(b) (6)Friday, September 17, 2010 9:44 AMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)Re: Expert Consultant (Manning)Dr. Huff is burning up some use/lose leave but answering his cell. It is(b) (6)RFOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02880682FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFrom:SenLTo:Subject:sir.Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJAMonday,Sepfember 20, 2010 12:02 PMMonow III,JoDean,CRT USAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA; (b) (6)RE: contact informafion (UNCLASSIFIED)Please see below.Oo you have any other suggestions!^Thank you.v/rAshdenAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. ArmyMilitary D i s t r i c t of Washington (MDW)(b) (6)UnclassifiedEmailRCM 706 0035FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221931From:Sent:To:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY(b) (6)Monday, September 20, 2010 2:04 PMFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)Morrow III, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA(b) (6)>RE: contact information (UNCLASSIFIED)aassification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats; NONEHow vvouU you feel about liiring a civilian? 1 migtu have some leads for qualified people witli TS clearance.Ru„c,a»«^ E.a,, RCM 706 0036FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY;02880685FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFrom:Sent:To:Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJAMonday.Sepfember 20, 20102:19 PM'(b) (6); Morrow III,JoDean, CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJASubject:Re: contact informafion (UNCLASSIFIEO)Sir. We rather not i f possible because of the protracted process. Our civilian would have togo through contracting and that cause an issue. I t would be more beneficial to have someonefrom bragg or nearby and we f l y them in when needed, ^r ashdenAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military Justice(b) (6)FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02205495From:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYf7 " ™-USA JFHQ-NCRMDW SJA(b) (6)Sent:To:Wednesday, September 22, 2010 4:08 PM'Mdone, Ricky D COL USSOUTHCOM JTFGTMO'(b) (6)Cc:Subject:Fdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)update (UNCLASSIFIED)(b) (6)>Classification; UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: FOUOSorry to bother you again on the forensic psychiatrist issue, but it occurred to us that you may be restricting your searchto folks with a TS/SCI clearance. At this point, a forensic psychiatrist with a SECRET clearance is sufficient and we canwork him through the upgrading process if need be. Let me know if you we can help you in any way.Respectfully,CPT Joe MorrowTrial CounselUS Army Military District of Washington(b) (6)Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: FOUOFOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02205493From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYMorrow HI, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA(b) (6)Wednesday, September 22, 2010 4:11 PM(b) (6)Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA aassification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: FOUOSir,COL Benedict is a go. Tlianks for all your work on iliis. Wlien you gel a cliancc, please send a good contact number for liim. Tlianksagain.CPT Joe MorrowTrial CounselUS Annv Militarv District of Wasliington(b) (6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0041FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02872832From:Sent:To:^c:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJAThursday, Ocfober14. 2010 10:02 PMSweda,MichaelGOrCI^ USA MEDCOM WRAMC: (b) (6)^immennan,SaraJSGT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJA; Fein,Ashden CPT USA JFHQNCR/MOW SJA; coombs@armycourtmartialdefense.com; Matthew kemkes; Morrow III,JoDean, CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA;Haberiand,JohnCPTUSARegimenfdJudgeAdvocafe: Rose, Luke CPTUSD-C SJA Chief Military JusticeRCM 706 (PFCManning)Gentlemen,Currently we are s t i l l delayed for the I^CM 706 for security matters. Att h i s point, we do not have an estimate on their completion, but once theyare then we should move d i r e c t l y i n the RCM 706 board, pending adetermination of security clearances. Thank you.v/rCPTFein-vAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. Army Military D i s t r i c t of Washington (MOW)(b) (6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0042FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221925From:Sent:To:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY(b) (6)Friday, October 15, 2010 8:10 AMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)(b) (6)Cc:Zimmennan, Sara J. SGT USA JFHQ- NCR/MDW SJA; coombs@armycourtmartialdefense.com;Matthew kemkes (b) (6); Monow III, JoDean, CPT USAJFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)l>; Haberiand, John(b)(6)CPT USA Regimental Judge .Advocate(b) (6)Subject:RE RCM 706 (PFC Manning) (UNCLASSIFIED)Classification; UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NONETliank vou.v/r.Micliael Sweda. Pli D.. ABPP (Forensic)Board-Certified Forensic PsychologistChief, Forensic Psy chology Serv iceDirector, Forensic Psv chology Fellowship Walter Reed Amiy Medical Center(b) (6)"The United States themselves are essentially Ihe greatest poem.Past and present and future arc nol disjoined bul joined "FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY>;02902034FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFrom:Sent:To:Subject:Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJAThursday,Noyember 04,20109:11 AM(b) (6)FW: Forensic Psychiatrist Support (UNCLASSIFIEO)Sir.FYSA Please ready b e l o w .COL Coffman i s t h e G a r r i s o n Commander, FT Myer and t h eS p e c i a l Court M a r t i a l Convening A u t h o r i t y .v/rAshdenAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. Army Military D i s t r i c t of Washington (MOW)(b) (6)FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02902030FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFrom:Sent:To:(b) (6)Subject:FW: ForensicPsychiatrist Support (UNCLASSIFIED)Sir.Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJAThursday,November 04,2010 1:11 PMFYSA.Ashden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. ArmyMilitary District of Washington (Mt^)(b) (6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0045FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221922From:Sent:To:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLY(b) (6)Thursday.Noveraber4, 20104 36PMFein, Ashden CPTUSAJFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)RE:ForensicPsychiatrisfSupport(UNCLASS1F1ED)CPTFein.lhad alrcady seen this inqtiirythroughOTSC channels and let them knowlcould support it lliavealrcadyseen him clinically forrisk management issues at Dr11oclcr'srcqucst(tlial'svvhyl'vebecnrecusedas an c;^pert),soIcan easily take over his care if need be^lalready Iiave credentials thereand have the clearance. CAPT Neill can contact me direetly.but it probably wodd be betterto havethe fonnal tasking aswell to cover me and maintiamcontintiilv".Regards,Rick Malone. MD.MPHCOLMCSFS(b) (6)Cliief Waller Reed Forensic Psy cliiatry Serv iceForensic Psy cliiatty Consultani to the Anny Siu-geon CeneralUSAAMA AeroiiiedicdPsy cliiairy Coiisultanl(b) (6)govUnclassified Email RCM 706 0046FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221921From:Sent:To:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLY(b) (6)Monday,December 13,20103:05 PMMorrow IILJoDean, CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA(b) (6)^;Fein, Ashden CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW(b)(6)SJA^^Manning 706(UNCLASSIFIED)Classification;UNCLASS1F1EDCaveatsFOUOIspoke to Dr. Sweda, the timeframe will depend toacertain extent onthe clearance issue. If it is TS, then there will be the logistics ofinterviews, storing documents, and perhaps evenreport-writinginaSCIF. We do have Secret storage available, so that wodd not present asmuchofadifficdty. Because it has been several months, obviouslythey have taken on other cases and will have court dates to work around.His time estimateremainsabout the same, especially given thehigh-profile nature ofthe case it is betterto be thorough andmeticulous about tlie 706 rather dian throwing it together ASAP. You canreach Dr. Sweda at 202-782-5899 to coordinate specifics.Regards,RickMa1one",MO,MPHCOL.MC.SFS(b) (6)ChieL Waller Reed Forensic Psychiatry Serv iceForensic Psychiatiy Consultant to the Army Surgeon CeneralUSAAMA Aeromedical Psydiiatty Consultant(b) (6)lhave the two toughest jobs in the militaty; Army Psychiatrist and NavySpouselClassificadon: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats; FOUO^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^706 00^7FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02885449From:Sent:To:Cc:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYSubject:Fein,Ashden CPT USAJFHQNCR/MDW SJAMonday,December 20,20106:59 PMSweda,MichadGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMC(b) (6); Morrowlll,JoDean, CPT USAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA;coombs@armycourtmartialdefensecom; Kemkes,MatthewJMAJMIL USAU S v B M (706 Board)Importance:HighSir,Good evening. The US v. PFC Manning case has now moved into the security clearance portionof the process. For t h i s , we w i l l need t o ensure a l l the personnel who w i l l be involved i nthe case have adequate clearances and appropriate read-ons. Can you please verify that thefollowing personnel w i l l be the members of the RCM 706 8oardi^ Thank you.706 8oard:Or. SwedaLTC SchneiderCPT(P) 8eneshv/rCPTFeinAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. Army Military D i s t r i c t of Washington (MOW)(b) (6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0048FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221919From:Sent:To:Cc:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY(b) (6)Tuesday, December 21, 2010 7:42 AMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)(b) (6); Monow 111, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ(b)(6)NCR/MDW SJA>;coombs@armycourtmartialdefense.coni; Matthew kemkes(b) (6)Subject:RE: US V. BM (706 Board) (UNCLASSIFIED)Classificauon; UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats; NONESirI can verif}' that myself and CPT Benesh will be members of llie Board.V/r.Micliael Sweda, Ph.D., ABPP (Forensic)Board-Certified Forensic PsycliologistChief Forensic Psychology ServiceDirector. Forensic Psv chologv Fellow ship Wdter Reed Armv Medical Center(b) (6)"The United States themselves are essentially tlie greatest poem.Pasi and preseiU and future arc nol disjoined bul joined "Unclassified Email RCM 706 0049FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYl>02221918FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFrom:Sent:To:Subject:(b) (6)LTuesday,December21,20108:00 AMFein, Ashden CPT USAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA ^(b) (6)Re: USvBM(706 Board)Will you be able fo expedite fhe requisite clearance if we subsitute forLTC SchneidersFOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02885447FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFrom:Sent:Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJATuesday,December 21,20109:53 AMTo:Subject:(b) (6)Re:USy BM (706 Board)S i r . Who would I t c s s u b s t i t u t e fori^ I thought o r i g i n a l l y there would be 3i^ We can expeditea l l clearances f o r anyone w i t h a secret.Ashden FeinCPT, JA(b) (6)FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221916FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYFrom:Sent:To:Subject:(b) (6)Tuesday, December 21, 2010 10:07 AMFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)Re: USv.BM (706 Board)>I would like to substitute LTC Hemphill for Schneider, she has more availability txit only has a Secret clearance af fhispoint.FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02885445FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFrom:Sent:To:Subject:Sir.Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJATuesday,Oecember 21,201010:18 AM(b) (6)Re: U S v BM (706 Board)Thanks. Could you p l e a s e send me h e r s s n .Ashden FeinCPT, JA(b) (6)FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221913From:Sent:To:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYMaria Hemphill (b) (6)Tuesday,December2l,2010 12:10PMMalone, RickyDCOL MIL USAMEDCOMWRAMC(b) (6); Fein, AshdenCPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA(b) (6)Cc:Subject:HemphllLMarlaRLTC MIL USA MEDCOMBAMC(b) (6)Re: Fw:USy BM (706 Board)CPTFein,Per thee-^mailstiingbelow,Iwould be tiie substitute forLTC Schneider.MySS^is5l060^174LTCHemphillMarlaHemphill.MDLTC, USA, MCForensic Psychiatry FellowWalter Reed Army Medical Center(b) (6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0054FOROFFICIALUSEONLY>02909033FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFrom:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:Sir.Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJAWednesday,Decemtier 29,2010 12:11 PM(b) (6)Morrow III,JoDean,CPT USAJFHQ-NCR/MDW SJAAvailable fhis weekAre you a v a i l a b l e t o discuss another a d m i n i s t r a t i v e issuel^v/rCPTFeinAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. Army Military D i s t r i c t of Washington (MOW)(b) (6)FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYThank you.02221912From:Sent:To:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY(b) (6)Wednesday, December 29, 2010 12:11 PMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)Out of Office: Avdlable this weekl>Iwill be unavailable unul Wednesday Januaty 5th. If you need assistance before then please contact the Forensic Admin AssL Ms.Williams, at (b) (6)FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02885276From:SenLTo:Cc:Subject:Attachments:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJAWednesday,January 12,2011 12:33 PM(b) (6)Monow III,JoDean,CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJAUSv.ManningForensic Psychiatrist Request pdfSir,Good afternoon. Attached i s a defense request to have COL 8enedek removed as the OefenseExpert Psychiatrist and Capt Moore appointed. The main reason f o r the defense's request i sthat they claim COL Oenedek did not o r i g i n a l l y understand the extent of his involvement.Although we do not f u l l y support t h e i r j u s t i f i c a t i o n , i t i s understandable and we w i l lpresent the request t o the Convening Authority. Oo you have any input as the Chief ofForensic Psychiatry on t h i s change and i t s impact on PFC Manning's care, future care, and theoverall missionsThank you.v/rCPTFeinAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. Army Military D i s t r i c t of Washington (MOW)(b) (6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0057FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221910From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLY(b) (6)Thursday.January 13,20119:45 AMFein, Ashden CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)Morrow IILJoDean, CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA^(b) (6)RE: USvManning (UNCLASSIFIED)Classificafion; UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NONENo impact CAPTBoctervvill be leaving next vveekandlvvill be asstimingresponsibilityfbrpsychiatric care of dlofhi^die Brig, including PFC Manning.UnclassifiedEmailRCM 706 0058FOROFFICIALUSEONLY^^^^^^^^From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein,AshdenCPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDWSJAWednesday,January19,20111:19PM(b) (6)Casamatta, JosephMCPTMIL USA TRADOC;'Haberland, John CPTMIL USAPFCBMS i r . Good afternoon. Are you a v a i l a b l e i n the next 24 bourns t o conduct a conference c a l lw i t h CPT Joe Casamatta (PFC Manning^s CO COR) and CPT John Haberland ( T r i a l Counsel dedicatedt o the 8 r i g coordination) i n order f o r them t o receive an update on PFC Manning^s mentalhealthi^ I f so, CPT Haberland w i l l setup the meeting at yout^ convenience.Thank you.v/rCPTFeinAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, M i l i t a r yJusticeU.S. Army M i l i t a r y D i s t r i c t of Washington (MOW)(b) (6)iltUnclassified EmailRCM 706 0059FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02203420From^FOROFFICIALUSEONLYCarlile, MonicaLSFC USAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA(b) (6)Sent:To:Cc:Subject:Friday,January2L201110:17AM(b) (6)Fein, Ashden CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)(UNCLASSIFIED)>Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveatsFOUOLTCHemphill,lam the Paralegal NCO assigned to the prosecuting team in US v. Manning. We need some information from you inorderto getthings rolling on yourTS/SCI upgrade. Ineed yourcity and state of birth, two contact numbers and an AI^Oemail address if you have one. If not, we will submit both ofthese addresses to C2forthem to send you links and otherdocumentation needed.^/rSFCCarlileSF(^1^CNI(^A(^ARLIL5PARAL^(^ALNCOU.S,Armyl^ilitaryDistrlctofWashington(l^DW)Icannotbe reached atthisoffice using ray (global accounL Please be sure to eraail aL(b) (6)ClassificationUNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: FOUO^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^06 0060FOROFFICIALUSEONLYO^ftftMMFOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYFrom:Sent:(b) (6)To:Subject:Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJAFriday, January 21, 2011 1 25 PMFw: US v. BM (706 Board)Larry. Below i s hemphill info. Thx.Ashden FeinCPT, JA(b) (6)u«Ema, RCM 706 cm,FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02885460FOROFFICIALUSEONLYSubject:Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJAFriday,Januaty 21,2011 11:13AM'Sweda,MichadGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMC(b) (6)'; Morrow III, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJA;'coombs@armycourtmartialdefensecom';'Kemkes, MatthewJMAJMIL USA'; Carlile,MonicaLSFC USA JFHQNCR/MOW SJAU S v B M (706 Board)Importance:HighFrom:Sent:To:Cc:Or. Sweda,Good morning. The purpose of t h i s email i s to give you an update on the RCM706 for PFC Manning. Although the board i s s t i l l delayed, we expect theclearance issue t o be resolved shortly. The Army G2 i s sending emails t othose participants, i n the overall CM process, that w i l l need t o complete"E (^IP" by Monday morning so t h e i r clearance approval can be expedited. Asfor the RCM 706 Board, t h i s w i l l only apply t o LTC Hemphill, a l l others havethe appropriate clearance. Once the clearances are approved f o r interim,then we w i l l schedule a date and time for a l l those who need t o be read on,to meet in Crystal City for t h e i r read on. I plan to give some lead timefor this and we w i l l l i k e l y plan early morning or late in the day t oaccommodate around work schedules. Once the read-ons are scheduled, then weexpect the Convening Authority t o issue a supplemental order f o r the RCM 706to restart with special instructions.Assuming no c r i t i c a l issues i n the remaining members SF86/E-0IP.^ Ianticipate the read-ons t o occur the week after next and the RCM 706 tostart again the following week.I f you have any questions, please send them to the entire emaildistribution.Thank you and have a good weekend,v/rCPT FeinAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. Army Military O i s t r i c t of Washington (MOW)(b) (6)UnclassifiedEmailRCM 706 0062FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02889461From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:Importance:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein,Ashden CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDWSJAFriday,January2L201111;18AM'coombs@armycourtmartialdefensecom':Autty,CarolynDMs Cl^ JFHQNCR/MOW SJA;Cariile, MonicaLSFC USAJFHQNCR/MDWSJA; Hemphill, MarlaRLTC MIL USAMEDCOM BAMC; (b) (6)Morrow III,JoDean,CPT USAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA;'Kemkes, MatthewJMAJMIL USASecurity Clearances (USv BM)HighMr. Coombs, LTC Hemphill, Ms. Autry, and SFC Carlile,Good morning. You should receive an email today ft^om either a OoO/OA entity ot^ OPMinstructing you t o f i l l out the digital SF 86on e-OlI^Lhrough theOPM website. Please spendthis weekend completing your e-OIP and submit before 1000hours on Monday morning. You w i l lbe able to use this system at home on your personal computer. Please email me and SFCCarlile once you complete this process. I f you have any questions over the weekend, pleasecall me on my 88. Thank you.LTC Hemphill- the above only applies i f we receive your personal information from out^previous email.Thank you and have a good weekendlv/rCPT FeinAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. Army Military Oistt^ict of Washington (MOW)(b) (6)Unclassified EmailRCM 706 0063FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY(b) (6),. • no» ...Unclassified Email RCM 706 0063FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221908FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFrom:Sent:To:Subject:(b) (6)Friday, January 21, 2011 1 00 PMFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)Re: US v. BM (706 Board)Does tliiit include me as the treating psychiatrist?un.,.si.ed Em,„ RCM TOO 0064FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYl>02885456FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFrom:Sent:Fein,/^hden CPT USA JFHQNCR/MDWSJAFriday, January 21, 2011 10:40 AMMaria Hemphill: Hemphill,MarlaRLTC MIL USA MEDCOM BAMC;To:(b) (6)Cc:Subject:Malone, RickyDCOL MIL USA MEOCOM WRAMC; Sweda, MichadGOrCI^USAMEDCOM WRAMC; Cariile, MonicaLSFC USAJFHQNCR/MDW SJAUSvBM (706 Board)HighImportance:LTCHemphill,Good morning. Could you please send us your place of b i r t h (City and State) so that we canexpedite your TS/SCI clearance. I f possible, we need this information ASAPI Thank you.v/rCPTFeinAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. Army Military DistrictofWashington (MOW)(b) (6)UnclassifiedEmail RCM 706 0(^5FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02203402FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYCarlile, Monica L. SFC USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJAFrom:(b) (6)Sent:To:Friday, January 21, 2011 1:38 PM'coombs@armycourtmartialdefense.com'; Autry, Carolyn D Ms CIV JFHQ-NCR/MDWSJA (b) (6)Cc:Subject:Fdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats; FOUOALL:Please see below. CPT Fein would like for it to be completed NLT Wednesday, 26 Feb 11, in order to keep the process movingswiftly.V/rSFC Carlile1. Arequirementprior to initiating your SSBI investigation is liaving yourfingerprints done in which shows in JPAS a few days later. Can you please goto the nearest Security Office/ local poUce station to get yourfingerprints done elecuonically via a Electronic Fingerprint machine ?Please enter the below infonnation intiieElecUonic Fingerprint machine inwhich will print out on thefingerprintcard (FD-258).INFORMATION NEEDED FOR FINGERPRINT CARD(FD-258)ADDRESS: HQDA ODCS, G-2, 1000 ARMY PENTAGON, WASHINGTON, DC 20310REASON: clearance upgradeSON: AROO (AR zero, zero)SOI: A334Enter in "ORI" block: USOPMOOOZ (US the letter "o", PM, zero, zero, zero,zulu)2. If your current organization does not have a Fingerprint machine, one isavailable on Fort Belvoir, VA.NOTE: Please call (b) (6)to ensuretiiatsomeone is available.9820 FLAGLER RD. BLDG 269, STE G2. RM 129,....oo.,Unclassified Email RCM 706 0066FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02203402FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFORTBELVOIR.VA 22060 59293.Ifyouare capability of completingyourfingerprints at your localpolice station but does not have an "ElecUomc Fingerprint" machine, pleasemail (FEDE^) thefingerprintcard (FO-258) to the befow addressSend VIA FEDEX (overnight if possible)DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMYPSI CENTER OF EXCELLENCEB3240/2201 ABERDEEN BLVDABERDEEN PROVING GROUND, fViD 21005-5001Please inform me of the method that you choose and when it was completed.v/rBONITA DAVISAssistant Security ManagerClassification; UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: FOUOFOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02902315FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYFrom:Sent:To:Subject:Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJAFriday, January 21, 2011 1:40 PMCariile, Monica L. SFC USA JFHQ-NCR/MOW SJA;'coombs@armycourtmartialdefense.com'; Autry, Carolyn 0 Ms CIV JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA;(b) (6)Re: FINGERPRINTS (UNCLASSIFIED)A l l . Just t o c l a r i f y 26 Jan 11 and not Feb. Thank you.Ashden FeinCPT, JA(b) (6)FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221906FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYFrom:Sent:To:Subject:(b) (6)LFriday, January 21, 2011 1:56 PMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA RE: FINGERPRINTS (UNCLASSIFIED)Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NONETracking number: 794346810944Unclassified Email RCM 706 0073FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYl>n^QOP-^IRFOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYFrom:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJASatunJay, January 22, 2011 12:35 PM(b) (6)Cariile, Monica L. SFC USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJARE: FINGERPRINTS (UNCLASSIFIED)Thank you ma'am.Ashden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. Army Military O i s t r i c t of Washington (MDW)(b) (6)un..ss« E^ai, RCM 706 0074FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02910828From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDWSJAWednesday, January 26, 2011 8:47 AM'Sweda, MichaelGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMC'(b) (6); Mon-ow 111,JoDean,CPTUSAJFHQNCF^MOW SJA706 General Questions (PFC Manning)Or. Sweda,Good morning. Are you available to discuss the administration of a 706i^ We are drafting thespecial instructions for PFC Manning^s 706 and have logistics questions. I am availableanytime to call. Thank you.y/rCPTFeinAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeO.S. Army M i l i t a r y O i s t r i c t o f Washington (MOW)(b) (6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0075FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02900573From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYFein, /kshden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJAWednesday, January 26, 2011 5:48 PM(b) (6)Davis, Bonifa N CIV USA DCS G-2Cariile, Monica L. SFC USA JFHQ-NCR/MOW SJAFW; Investigation Status Update - Processing, Ticket No. CLR000000084588(UNCLASSIFIEO)A l l . Can you please c l a r i f y what exactly you need from LTC Hemphill so she can f i n a l i z e theprocess? I t h i n k we are a l l confused. According t o FedEx (Tracking*: 794346810944), herf i n g e r p r i n t card was d e l i v e r e d t o Aberdeen on 24 Jan 11 at 0953 and signed f o r by"Strickland."Thank you.v/rCPT FeinAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, M i l i t a r y JusticeU.S. Army M i l i t a r y O i s t r i c t of Washington (MOW)(b) (6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0076FOROFFICIAL USE ONLY02900565From:Sent:To:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein,Ashden CPTUSAJFHQ-NCR/MDWSJAWednesday.January 26,2011 5:49 PMHemphill,MariaRLTC MIL USA MEOCOM BAMCFW: Investigafion Status Update-Processing,Ticket No CLR000000084588(UNCLASSIFIED)FWOAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. Army Military O i s t r i c t of Washington (MOW)(b) (6)Original MessageFrom: Fein, AshdenCPTUSA JEH^NCR/MOW SJASent: Wednesday, January 26, 2011 5:48 PMTo: (b) (6)^ Davis, Bonita N CI^ USA OCS G 2Cc: Carlile, Monica L. SFCUSA JFHONCR/MOWSJASubject: FW: Investigation Status UpdateProcessing, Ticket No. CLR000000084588(UNCLASSIFIEO)A l l . Can you please c l a r i f y what exactly you need from LTC Hemphill so she can f i n a l i z e theprocess? I think we are a l l confused. According to FedEx (Trackingff: 794346810944), herfingerprint card was delivered t o Aberdeen on 24 Jan 11 at 0953 and signed f o r by"Strickland."Th9nl^ you.v/rCPTFeinAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. Army Military O i s t r i c t of Washington (MOW)(b) (6)1Unclassified Email RCM 706 0077FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02900560From:SenLTo:Cc:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJAWednesday, January 26, 2011 6:27 PM'(b) (6)';'Davis, BonifaNCIV USADCSG2': Rains, LarryEMrC1VUSADCSG2; Hemphill,MarlaRLTC MIL USA MEOCOMBAMCCarlile,MonicaLSFC USA JFHQNCR/MDW SJARE: Investigation Status Update-Processing,Ticket No. CLR000000084588(UNCLASSIFIED)ALCON. There i s a disconnect on email d i s t r i b u t i o n f o r t h i s issue because i n c o r r e c t emailscopied over. Please reply t o a l l using t h i s email. Below i s from Mr. Rains.All,I'm sure i t ' s i n the mailroom and w i l l get t o the PSI Team soon,enormous volume of m a i l , e s p e c i a l l y Fedex. Please be p a t i e n t .Best regards,LarrySent v i a BlackBerryAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, M i l i t a r y j u s t i c eU.S. A r m y M i l i t a r y D i s t r i c t o f W a s h i n g t o n (MOW)(b) (6)UnclassifiedEmailRCM 706 0078FOROFFICIALUSEONLYThe PSI CoE receives an02232112From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLY(b il^Cunningham,RobertFMr CIV USA (b) (6))Thuisday,January 27,20117:19 AM(6Fein, Ashden CPTUSAJFHQ-NCR/^^DW SJA ^(b) (6)il^;)(b) (6)m;Hemphill,MarlaRLTCMILUSAMEDCOMBAMC(b) (6)^CarlileMonicaLSFC USAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA^(b) (6)l^,Rains, LarryEMr CIV USA DCS G-2(b)(6)^il^; Davis, BonitaNClV USA DCS G-2^(b) (6)^RE: Investigation Status Update Processing, TicketNoCLR000000084588(UNCLASSIFIED)Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NONELTCHempldlandCPTFeinThefingerprintrequirementis good-the print check completedyesterday and posted to JCAVS T1^ onlyreqdremeniwe still needfromLTC Hemphill is to make some corrections to Ihe e-t^lP and release back tothe PSl-CoE (if not already done-APG hasadelayed openiiig until 1000 this monnngsolcan't see iftiienevve-^IP is ready to reviewyeti The nevve-(^IPsignature pages tliat m^itch the investigation number.Ifyou liave any" other questions/concerns, please k^i me know Sorry fbrtiieconfusion with die belowe-maifBobbvV/RRobertF.CunninghamPersonnel Security InvestigationCenter ofExcellence(b) (6)(b) (6)UnclassifiedEmailRCM 706 0079FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221896From:Sent:To:Cc:Subjecl:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYMaria Hemphill Thursday, January 27, 2011 7:41 AMCunningham, Robert F Mr CIV USA (b) (6)l>(b)(6)Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA>;Hemphill,Marla R LTC MIL USA MEDCOM BAMC (b) (6)l>;Cariile, Monica L. SFC USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA(b) (6)>, Rains, Larry E Mr CIV USA DCS G-2(b) (6)Davis, Bonifa N CIV USA DCS G-2Thursday, January 27, 2011 4:19 PM(b) (6); Fdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA(b) (6)Cc:Subject:Cariile, Monica L. SFC USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJARE: Investigation Status Update - Processing, Ticket No. CLR000000084588(UNCLASSIFIED)Classification; UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NONELTC Hemphill,Ifyou havetiiemscanned and in e-QIP. vve shodd not need tlieni. 1 will have one ofmy folks pull the case and take a look for me.BobbyV/RRobert F. CunninghamPersomiel Security Im cstigalionCenter of Excellence(b) (6)(b) (6),r..Unclassified Email RCM 706 0085FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221883From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:Attach:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYMaria Hemphill (b) (6)Thursday.Januai^ 27,20115:46 PMDavis, BonifaNCIVUSA DCS G-(b) (6)RobertFMrCIV USA (b) (6)JFHQ NCR/MDW SJA ^(b) (6)^^; Cunningham,l^; Fein, Ashden CPTUSA(b) (6)Re: (U) RE: Investigation Status Update Processing, Ticket No CLR000000084588(UNCLASSIFIED)Hemphill,Maria releasesOl271lpdfHerearefhesignature pagesv/r,LTCHemphillUnclassifiedEmailRCM 706 0086FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02891837From:SenLTo:Cc:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYSubject:Attachments:Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJAThursday, February 03, 2011 7:42 PMSweda,MichadGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMCcoombs@armycourtmartialdefensecom; Benesh,SamanthaMCPT MIL USA MEDCOMMAMC; Hemphill,MarlaRLTC MIL USA MEDCOM BAMC; Morrowlll,JoDean,CPT USAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA; Cariile,MonicaLSFC USAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA;(b) (6)RCM 706Order (PFCBM)11Feb^03 RCM 706 Order pdfImportance:HighOr. Sweda,Good evening. Attached i s the Convening Authority's order to re-start theRCM 706 Board for PFC Manning. The prosecution intends to prepare thea l l i e d documents t o send to you and your team early next week. I f you haveany questions, please ask. Thank you.v/rCPT FeinAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. Army Military O i s t r i c t of Washington (MOW)(b) (6)UnclassifiedEmailRCM 706 0087FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221882From:Sent:To:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY(b) (6)Friday, Februaiy 4, 2011 7:42 AMFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA 02891829From:Sent:To:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJAFriday,Februaty 04,2011 8:00 AM(b) (6)RE: RCM 706 Order (PFCBM) (UNCLASSIFIED)Or. Sweda,The OA Security personnel confirmed you are already read-on to SI/TI^/G/HCS. Are you underthe impression that you are not?v/rCPTFeinAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. Army Military O i s t r i c t of Washington (Mf^)(b) (6)UnclassifiedEmailRCM 706 0089FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221879From:Sent:To:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYM(b) (6)Friday,February 4,2011815AMFein, Ashden CPTUSAJFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA ^(b) (6)RE:RCM 706Order(PFCBM)(UNCLASSlFIED)>ClassificationUNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NOf^Sir;lliave been read on in the past in anotiier case lliave made limited use of mysecurityclearance in the past and am not thoroughlyfamiliarwith tlie procedures Itliought the read on might beaease-by-case issue, bulnowlknowil is not.v/rMichael Sweda. PhD.ABPP (Forensic)Board-Certified Forensic PsychologistCliieL Forensic Psy cliology Serv iceDirector. Forensic Psvchologv Fellowship WalterRe^ Amiv Medical Center(b) (6)"TheUiiitedStatesthemselvesareessentiallytiiegreatestpoemPast and present and future are not disjoined but joined."^^^^^^^^^^^^Unclassified Email RCM 706 0090FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02215541From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYcoombs@armycourtmartialdefense.comMonday,Februaty^7,20118:46 AMFein, Ashden CPTUSAJFFIQNCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)l>Benesh,SamantiiaMCPTM1L USAMEDCOMMAMC(b) (6);Heraphill,MarlaRLTC MIL USAMEDCQMBAMC (b) (6)^;MonowIILJoDean, CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)il>, Carlile, MonicaL SFCUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA ^(b) (6)>; Matthew(b)(6)kemkesSweda,MichadGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMC(b) (6)>;MooreKeyin(b) (6)^|^SuspectedSPAMjRE:RCM 706Order(PFCBM)Or.Sweda,The R.C.I^. 706 order indicates that the defense would like CapL l^eyinl^oore to be permitted to "monitorthe examinations conducf;ed by metnbers of the board," Iwould like to clarify that the defense does notwant CapL l^oore to participate in the 706 board or to intetjed himself in any manner during the board.We simply request that CapL I^oore be allowed to sit while the board conducts its work. The goal of thisrequest is so that he could be inabetter position to educate defense counsel on the board's testing aridresults.Additionally,although the convening authority has givenafour week suspense date for completion of theboard,the defense views this suspense as aspirationaf Clearly,you and the board should feel free to takethe time necessary to conductathorough and complete examination of PFC IManning. If the boardrequires an extension of time,you should feel free to submit sucharequest through the trial counsel.Undoubtedly,any request for an extension of time by the board would be granted. In the end,the mostimport;ant thing is that the board takes the time it needs to in order to feel comfortable with its results.BesLDavidDavid E.Coombs, Esq.Law Office of David E.Coombs45 North l^ain Street, 5th FloorFall River,I^A 02720Office:1^005^^4156Fax: (50^)324 9^96^^ombs^^riTiyi;;o^^^^www.aFmycourtmartialdefense.coni'^**ConfidentialityNotice:This transmission,induding attachments, may contain confidential attorneyclient information and is intended for the person(s)or company named. If you are not the intendedrecipienL please notify the sender and delete all copies. Unauthorized disclosure, copying or use of thisinformation may be unlawful and is prohibited.***FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02891868From:SenLTo:Cc:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJAMonday, Febmary 07, 2011 8:50 AMcoombs@armycourtmartia1defense.comBenesh,SamanfhaMCPT MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC; HemphilfMariaRLTC MIL USAMEDCOM BAMC; Mon^ow III, JoDean,CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA; Cariile, MonicaLSFC USA JFHQ-NCF^MDW SJA; Matthew kemkes; (b) (6);Sweda,MichadGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMCRCM 706 (PFCBM)Or. Sweda,Good morning. The prosecution has a compact disk of documents t o set^ve as the a l l i e ddocuments for this case. What i s the best way t o ensure prompt delivery t o you and theboard? Thank you.v/rCPTFeinAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. Army Military O i s t r i c t of Washington (MOW)(b) (6)UnclassifiedEmailRCM 706 0092FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221876From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:Signed By:Classification:Caveats: NONEFOROFFICIALUSEONLY(b) (6)Monday, Febmary 07, 2011 2:36 PMFein, Ashden CRT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJA; coombs@armycourtmartialdefense.com(b) (6);Monow111,JoDean,CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDWSJA; Cariile,MonicaLSFC USAJFHQNCF^DW SJA; Matthewkemkes;(b) (6)RE; RCM 706 (PFCBM) (UNCLASSIFIED)BENESHSAMANTHAMARIE 1272647034UNCLASSIFIEOCPT Fein,Dr. Sweda w i l l be out of the office the rest of this week^ please send thedisk to my attention via courier or Fed Ex t o the following address:ATTN: MAJ Samantha Benesh6900 Georgia Ave, N.W.Bldg 6/Borden Pavilion, 3rd FloorDepartment of PsychologyWashington, OC 20307Please do NOT send the disk via USPS/regular mail. Our mail system at WRAMC i snotorious for losing letters or delivering them only after a significantdelay.v/r,Samantha M. BeneshMAJ, MS, USAForensic Psychology FellowWalter l^eed Army Medical Center(b) (6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0093FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221875From:Sent:To:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY(b) (6)Monday, February 7, 2011 3:12 PMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA 02221871FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFrom:SenLTo:Subject:Attachments:Signed ^y:(b) (6)Monday, Febmary 07, 2011 3:52 PMFein, Ashden CRT USAJFHQ-NCR/MDWSJARE; RCM 706 (PFCBM) (UNCLASSIFIED)Benesh Protedive Order.POFBENESHSAMANTHAMARIE 1272647034FollowUpFlag:FlagStatus:FollowupCompletedClassification:Caveats: NONEUNCLASSIFI50CPT Fein,My signed acknowledgement of receipt of Protective Order in the case of PFCManning i s attached.v/r,Samantha M. BeneshMAJ, MS, USAForensic Psychology FellowWalter Reed Army Medical Center(b) (6)5Unclassified Email RCM 706 0095FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221869From:Sent:To:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY(b) (6)Monday, February 7, 2011 3:59 PMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)RE: RCM 706 Order (PEC BM) (UNCLASSIFIED)l>ClassificationUNCLASSIFIEDCaveatsNONESirIftiieacknowledgmeiit fonn regardingreceiptof the protective orderneeds to be sigiied and notartzed.Iatteiiipted to do so today atthe WRAMC JAGoffice Ivvasinfomied by the only slaff member on duty vvho isaiiolary that she codd not notarize it sincelamaDA civilian.Please tell llie ifyou need it notarizcdverstisjust witnessed, oreven sillily acknowledged,y/r,Micliael Sweda. PIiD.ABPP (Forensic)Board-Certified Forensic Psy cliologistCliieL Forensic P^cliology ServiceDirector. Forensic Psvchology Fellowship WalterReed Anny Medical Cei^er(b) (6)(b) (6)"Tlie United States themselves are essentially the greatest poem.Past and present andfiitureare not disjoined but joined "u n * s s « Ema, RCM 706 0006FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02891835From:SenLTo:Cc:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJAMonday,Febmary 07,2011 5:53 PM(b) (6)Cariile, Monica SFC MIL USA OTJAGRE: RCM 706 Order (PFCBM) (UNCLASSIFIED)Sir,Please have the entire board sign the actual document. I t does not need to be notarized.Thank you.Ashden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. ArmyMilitary Oistrict of Washington (MOW)(b) (6)Unclassified EmailRCM 706 0097FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02891831From:SenLTo:Cc:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJAMonday, February 07, 2011 6:08 PMFein, Ashden CRT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJA;'(b) (6)'Carlile, Monica SFC MIL USA OTJAG'RE: RCM 706Order(PFCBM) (UNCLASSIFIEO)Sir,As a point of clarification, please do have i t notarized or sworn before someone with theauthority to swear. Thank you.Ashden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. Army Military Oistrict of Washington (MOW)(b) (6)UnclassifiedEmailRCM 706 0098FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221866From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY(b) (6)Tuesday, February 8, 2011 7:48 A M(b) (6)(b) (6)(b) (6)Fdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJAMICHAEL.K.WESTl@US.ARMY.MILRE: RCM 706 Order (PFC BM) (UNCLASSIFIED)Classification; UNCLASSIFIEDCav eats; NONECPTKobrinski;Is there sonieone in tbe WIL^MC JAGoffice vvho codd assist ine tod^ vvithgettingafbrmnolarized'^lvvill be leaving for Ft.Ruckerlomorrow.andvviti be busy withacasetiiereall week.Tliankyodv/r,Micliael Sweda PliD ABPP(Foreiisic)Board-Certified Forensic Psy chologistChief Forensic Psy chology Serv iceDirector. Forensic Psvchologv Fellowship Walter Reed Amiv MedicalCcnter(b) (6)(b) (6)"The United Slaleslhemselves are essentially the greatest poem.Past and present and future are not disioined but joined."und,.m.d Em., RCM 706 OOOOFOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221864From:Sent:To:Subject:Attach:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY(b) (6)Tuesday, February 8. 2011 1:53 PMFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)FW: Scan from a Xerox WorkCentre Pro (UNCLASSIFIED)SeanOOlPDFClassification; UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NONESinAcknowledgement fonn (notarized) is attaclied.v/r.Michael Sweda, Ph D . ABPP (Forensic)Boad-Ccnified Forensic Psy chologistChief Forensic Psychology ServiceDirector. Forensic Psychology Fellowship Walter Reed Army Medical Center(b) (6)"The United States themselves are essentially llie greatest poem.Past and present and future are not disjoined but joined."FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02889770FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYFrom:Sent:To:SubjectFein. Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJATuesday, February 08, 2011 11:27 PM(b) (6)RE: Scan from a Xerox WoritCentre Pro (UNCLASSIFIED)Thank you s i r .Ashden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. Army Military O i s t r i c t of Washington (MOW)(b) (6)FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221863From:Sent:To:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY(b) (6)Tuesday, February 8, 2011 11:27 PMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA I am scheduled to be out of the office from 9 Feb through 11 Feb. 1 may bereachedfor urgent or other matters via cell (b) (6)milOr, contact my Deputy Chief Dr. Pad Montalbano at(b) (6)(b) (6)FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY30t-02221862FOROFFICIALUSEONLY(b) (6)LFrom:Sent:Wednesday,February9,20115:16AMTo:Fein, Ashden CPTUSAJEHQNCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)(b) (6)Cc:Subject:Initid planforeyaluafionschedule(UNCLASSIEIED)^Classification; UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats; NONECPTFein;Ibelieve MarlaHemphill has been out of contact down in GTMO but will be back in the CONUS soon. We are discussing probabledates forthe evaluation ofl6and 17 Feb andlMarch, with the 16th being an interview,the 17th psychological testing, andlMarchaninterviewataSCIF.Wewill need to know where tiie SCIF location will be. Anadditional date for testing may be needed,depending on how things go thel7th.Iwill get back to youas soon as possibleregardingtherequestto have CAPT Moore sit in on the interview. At present,just to assistin p1aiimng,ltlui^ he shodd nid^earraiigenients to attend the two interviews(I6Feb andlMarch), pending my havingfurtherdiscussions withthe other board members, lhave not vet been able to discuss therequestwith board members asagronp due toLTCHemphill's TDYIstrongly feel that observation of tiie testing is not advisable, as tills may liave unknown effectson the testresdtsandthe testing (ifobserved byathirdparty)would not be performed inastandatdizedfashion.Weask that CAPT Moore adiust his schedule to the board's plans. Otherwise,scheduling becomes unwieldy and the evaluation willundoubtedy be delayed as we try to coordinate four different schedules. Please tell him to call me at(b) (6)16ifhe hasquestions. Iwill be atFlRuckertiiis week onaTDY.Please forward thiseniail(defense counsel) to others as needed.Micliael SwedaClassification; UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NONE,^^a^.^Em.,RCM 706 0^o^FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02900769From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJAWednesday, Februaiy 09, 2011 6:49 AM(b) (6)L(b) (6);coombs@armycourtmartialdefense com; Mon-ow 111, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MOWSJA: Matthew kemkes: (b) (6); Haberiand, John CPT MIL USARE: Initial plan for evaluation schedule (UNCLASSIFIEO)Or. Sweda,Thank you.(paragraphthe extentinquiry."CCed are the defense counsel. As per the convening authority's guidance5, order dated 3 Feb 11, you as the Board president are authorized to "determineto which the defense expert consultant ^CAPT Moorej may participate i n the board'sAt t h i s point, t h i s decision i s s t r i c t l y up to you.I f you feel CAPT Moore's participation w i l l hinder the administrative process and/or affectthe board's test results and testing, and you want to exclude him from the overall process,t h i s i s completely up t o you. The defense would then have to re p e t i t i o n the conveningauthority to change his guidance. However, i f you feel that CAPT Moore can f u l l yparticipate, or participate i n some manner (less than f u l l ) , then you may approve that aswell.To reiterate what Mr. Coombs stated i n his email on Monday, 7 Feb 11, the most importantaspect of this RCM 706 (and a l l others) i s that the board has adequate enough time t ocomplete the process and i s comfortable with the results. I f CAPT Moore's participationaffects the results, then you are empowered to exclude him from the process.For the 16th and 17th, where do you envision the interview and testing t o take place (WRAMC)?I f at WRAMC, i s i t possible to schedule both during off-set hours? Pending contraryguidance, we w i l l start making tentative plans f o r you to meet with PFC M i n a SCIF on 1 Mar.We are s t i l l working on the location, but i t w i l l l i k e l y be i n or around Ft Belvoir, ^A.v/rCPTFeinAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, M i l i t a r y JusticeU.S. Army M i l i t a r y O i s t r i c t of Washington (MOW)(b)(6)UnclassifiedEmailRCM 706 0104FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221859From:Sent:To:Cc:FOROFFICIALUSEONLY(b) (6)Wednesday,Febrtiary9,20II7:52AMFein, Ashden CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)(b) (6)coombs@armycourtmartialdefense cora; Morrow HI, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQNCR/MDW SJA ^(b) (6)Subject:RE: Initid plan forevaluationschedule(UNCLASSlFIED)ClassificationUNCLASSIFIEDCaveatsNONESir;Weplan to evduate at the (quantico brig if al all possible Idot^tperfomievdualioiisofindividudswIioareeoiifinedatWRMACfbr securiiy and other reasonsWevvitiget back toyouabotitCAPTMoore's possible participation through unobti:usive observation forthe interviewsevaluation lain clearthat his presence dtiring the psychological testing pliases is undesirable fromastandpoint of staticadministration.Michael SwedaUnclassifiedEmailRCM 706 0105FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221853From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY(b) (6).MILFriday, February 11, 2011 6:43 AMFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA RE: Initial plan for evaluation schedule (UNCLASSIFIED)Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats; NONECPT Fein:I Iiav e considered the request for CAPT Moore to attend ihe interv iew ponrons oftiieevaluation, and 1 am willing to accommodate therequest specifically to increase tlx: nansparency of the process. Ideally tiic inten iew should be observ ed through a one way mirror. Ibelieve tliis arrangement is avmlable at Quantico. Ifa SCIF can be chosen with a one way mirror that would be ideal, but is not anabsoluterequirement(jusl a desirable feature).We request that CAPT Moore strictly adhere to observation ofthe interviews only, and not meet witii tlie accused during bnsaks orotlicrvvisc interact w itii him during the interviews.MAJ Benesh will begin w ith testing on Tucs 16 Feb. Wed 17 Feb will be the first interview at Quantico. If you could contact the brigfor me to arrange for use of appropriate space, as 1 am on TDY now, I wodd appreciate it. The SCIF interview dale will be agreedupon early next week.Tliank you!Micliael SwedaUnclassified Email RCM 706 0106FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221850From:Sent:To:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY(b) (6)Cc:Friday, February 11, 2011 6:49 AMMICHAEL.SWEDA@US ARMY.MIL; Fdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA(b) (6)>(b) (6);coombs@amiycourtmartialdefense.com; Morrow IB, JoDean, CPT USA JEHQNCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)>; Matthew kemkes(b) (6)a; Benesh, Samantha M MAJ MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC(b) (6); Morrow III,JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)>;(b) (6)Matthew kemkes (b) (6)Haberland, John CPT MIL USA (b) (6)l>; Carlile, Monica SFCMIL USA OTJAG (b) (6)il>RE: Initial plan for evaluation schedule (UNCLASSIFIED)Subject:aassification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NONESirWe will do the non-classified portions of the evaluation at Quantico. Tliank you for getting us a new CD.We plan on starting the evaluation on tiie 16tii al 0830, allowing for a possible delay due to traffic, which on occasion is vciy difficult,y/r,Michael Sweda, Ph D,. ABPP (Forensic)Board-Certified Forensic PsychologistChieL Forensic Psy chology ServiceDirector, Forensic Psvchologv Fellowship Walter Reed Army Medical Center(b) (6)Tlic United States themselves arc essentially the greatest poem.Pjtet and present and future are not disjoined but joined."Unclassified Email RCM 706 0110FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221842FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYFrom:Sweda, Michael G Dr CIV USA M E D C O M W R A M C(b) (6)Sent:Tuesday, February 15, 2011 11:56 A MTo:Moore, Kevin D. CAPT (b) (6)(b) (6)Benesh, Samantiia M MAJ MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC(b) (6); coombs(®arniycourtmartialdefense.com; Morrow HI,JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJ A (b) (6)>;Matthew kemkes (b) (6);Haberland, John CPT MIL USA (b) (6)>; Carlile, Monica SFCMIL USA OTJAG (b) (6)>; Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQNCR/MDW SJA Wednesday, March 2, 2011 11:17PMFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)Out of Office: RCM 706-Additional Charges (US v. PFC BM)1 am scheduled to be out oftiieoffice 1, 3, and 4 March. I may be reached for urgent or other matters via cell (b) (6)Or, contact my Deputy Chief Dr. Paul Montalbano (b) (6)mifFOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY>(b) 16.(6)02891811From:Sent:To:Cc:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYSubject:Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJAWednesday,March 02,2011 11:19PMSweda, MichadGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMCBenesh,SamanthaMMAJ MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC;coombs@armycourtmartia1defense.com; Morrow 111, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW; Haberiand, John CPT MIL USA;SJA: Matthew kemkes; (b) (6)Cariile,Monica SFC MIL USA OTJAG; HemphilfMarlaRLTC MIL USA MEOCOM BAMCRCM 706^Addifiona1 Charges (USvPFCBM)Importance:HighOr. Sweda,Also, could you please provide an estimated timeline for when the RCM 796board w i l l be complete. The convening authority's order, dated 3 Feb 11,gave a suspense of four weeks to complete the board. I assume because youhave not met with the accused, that you w i l l need an extension of time. Asper the convening authority's order, please provide an extension request.Thank you.v/rCPT FeinAshden FeinCPT, JAChief, Military JusticeU.S. Army Military Oistrict of Washington (MDW)(b) (6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0114FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02202551From^Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYMorrow IB, JoDean, CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA^(b) (6)Thursday,March 3,2011 1:23 PM'(b) (6)Fein, Ashden CPTUSAJEHQNCR/MDW SJA ^(b) (6)PFCManning(UNCLASSIEIED)l^ClassificationUNCLASSIFIEDCaveatsFOUOSir,lapologi^e for contacting you while on leave. PFC Manning was placed on suicide watch last night because of commentshe made to the brig staff,short1y after being served with additional charges. Col Choike, the Marine garrisoncommander,is concerned that Manning has no one to talk with while youare away. Do you have an alternative oranyone you trust to speak witb Manning? Anyone in the behavioral health communitythat we should notify about hischange in status7Respectfully,CPT Joe MorrowTrial CounselU.S.Army Military District ofWashington ^MDW)(b) (6)ClassificationUNCLASSIFIEDCaveatsFOUOFOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221840From:Sent:To:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYMdone, Ricky D COL MIL USA MEDCOM WRAMC>Thursday, March 3. 2011 1:34 PMMon-ow III, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA(b) (6)(b) (6)Cc:Subject:Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA 1 spoke with CW02 Barnes this morning. 111 stop by and see him on my way home tomorrow. 1 don't thrik they would changeanything at fhis point anyway. He did request a preference for a female psychologist, which I am working on. There's a newone joining our tele-psych service who lives in the area, her boss agreed to have her see him when she completes thecredentialing process. I'll contact you about getting her cleared v/hen she comes on board.Regards,Rick Malone, MD, MPHCOL, MC, SFS(b) (6)Director, Center for Forensic Behavioral SciencesForensic Psychiatry Consultant to the Army Surgeon GeneralUSAAMA Aeromedical Psychiatiy Consultant(b) (6)govUnclassified Email RCM 706 0116FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02202547From:Sent:To:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYMon-ow III, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA>Thursday, March 3,2011 1:37 PM'Mdone, Ricky D COL MIL USA MEDCOM WRAMC(b) (6)(b) (6)Cc:Subject:Fdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)RE: PFC Manning (UNCLASSIFIED)>Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats; FOUOTlianks for die update Sir. Again, som to bother you w hile you're on leave, bul I guess CW02 Bames did not update her/his chain ofcommand.CM Joe MorrowTrial CounselU.S. Annv Militarv District of Washington (MDW)(b) (6)(b) (6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0117FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02202543From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYMon^owBLJoDean, CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA^j(b) (6)^Thursday,March 3,20111:58 PM'Malone, RickyDCOL MIL USAMEDCOMWRAMC^( (b) (6)bFein,Ashden CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA ^(b) (6))RE:( PFC Manning (UNCLASSIFIED)^6)ClassificationUNCLASSIFIEDCaveals;FOUOSir,One last question-Is tliereanytiiing tlie brig needs to do medically before tomorrows Anyone we shodd contact'^ Anyadditionalsafely measures'^CPT Joe MorrowTrialCounsclUS AmiyMilitarvDistrict ofWashington (MDW)(b) (6)UnclassifiedEmail RCM 706 0118FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221838From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYSweda, Michael G Dr CIV USA MEDCOM WRAMC(b) (6)Thursday, March 3, 2011 2:07 PMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA Benesh, Samantha M MAJ MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC; Hemphill, Maria R LTC MIL USA(b) l>; Moore, Kevin D. CAPTMEDCOM BAMC (b) (6)(6)Benesh,Samantha M MAJ MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC; Matthew kemkes(b) (6); Haberland.JohnCPT MIL USA (b) (6)il>; Carlile,Monica SFC MIL USA OTJAG(b) (6)Hemphill,Maria R LTC MIL USA MEDCOM BAMC; Moore,Kevin D. CAPT(b) (6)l>; Sweda,Michad G Dr CIV USA MEDCOMWRAMC Monday, March 7, 2011 2:25 PM'Mdone, Ricky D COL MIL USA MEDCOM WRAMC(b) (6)(b) (6)Cc:Subject:Fdn, Ashden CPT USA TFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: FOUOSir,If you have a moment today, 1 was wondering whether I could ask you a few questions about a defense request forappointment of a neuropsychologisL Thanks.CPT Joe MorrowTrial CounselU.S. Army Military District of Washington (MDW)(b) (6)Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: FOUOFOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221835From:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYMdone, Ricky D COL MB. USA MEDCOM WRAMC(b) (6)Sent:To:Monday, March 7, 2011 3:20 PMMorrow III, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA(b) (6)I>Cc:Fein, Ashden CPT USA JEHQ-NCRMDW SJA Tuesday, March 8, 2011 11:04 PMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)l>Benesh, Samantha M MAJ MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC(b) (6)coombs@armycourtmartialdefense.com; Morrow HI,JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA ;Matthew kemkes (b) (6);Haberiand, John CPT MIL USA (b) (6)>; Cariile, Monica SFCMIL USA OTJAG (b) (6); Hemphill, Maria R LTC MIL USAMEDCOM BAMC ; Moore, Kevin D. CAPTWednesday, March 9, 2011 4:30 PMil>Fdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)Out of Office: RCM 706-Additional Charges (US v. PFC BM) (UNCLASSIFIED)1 am scheduled to be out of the office 7 Marchtiiomgh10 March. I may bereachedfor urgent or other matters via cell (b) (6)(b) (6) 6. Or, contact my Deputy Chief Dr. Paul Montalbano (b) (6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0128FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY-02221827From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYSweda, Michael G Dr CIV USA MEDCOM WRAMCFriday, March 11, 2011 8:43 AMFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)Benesh, Samantha M MAJ MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC(b) (6)coonibs@armycourtmartialdefense.com; Morrow HI,JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)Matthew kemkes (b) (6)Haberiand, John CPT MIL USA (b) (6)>; Carlile, Monica SFCMIL USA OTJAG Monday, March 14, 2011 7:49 AMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA Benesh, Samantha M MAJ MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC;(b) (6)(b) (6)Subject:RE RCM 706-Additiond Charges (US v. PFC BM) (UNCLASSIFIED)Classification; UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats; NOl^JECPT Fein:MAJ Benesh is on leave on that date (2 April),v/r,Micliael Sweda. Ph.D.. ABPP (Forensic)Board-Certified Forensic Psy cliologistChieL Forensic Psy chology ServiceDirector. Forensic Psv chologv Fellow ship Walter Reed Armv Medical Center(b) (6))"Tlic United States themselves are essentiallytiiegreatest poem.Past and present and future are not disjoined but joined,"FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02891790From:SenLTo:Cc:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYSubject:Fein, Ashden CRT USAJFHQNCR/MDW SJAMonday,March 14,2011 8:47 AMSweda,MichadGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMCBenesh,SamanthaMMAJ MIL USA MEOCOM MAMC;coombs@armycourtmartia1defense.com; Mon^ow 111, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MOWSJA: Matthew kemkes; (b) (6); Habertand, John CPT MIL USA;Cariile,MonicaLSFC USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA: Hemphill,MariaRLTC MIL USAMEDCOM BAMC;(b) (6)RE: RCM706^Additiona1Charges(USy PFCBM) (UNCLASSIFIED)Importance:HighSir,Thank you. We w i l l start making arrangements for the board to meet in another f a c i l i t y thatprovides security and privacy of the accused. Could you please send me the soonest date,after 26 March that the entire board is available.Also, does the board require the accused's movement to WRAMC or another f a c i l i t y for anytesting, IAW the convening authority's order?v/rCPTFeinAshden FeinCPT, JAUnclassified Email RCM 706 0132FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221820From:Sent:To:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYSweda, Michael G Dr CIV USA MEDCOM WRAMC>Monday, March 14, 2011 9:52 AMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)RE: RCM 706-Additional Charges (US v. PFC BM) (UNCLASSIFIED)(b) (6)Classification; UNCLASSIFIEDCaveatsNONESirDoyou warn me to provide an extensionrequestattiiistime7y/r.Micli^ielSwedaPliD ABPP (Forensic)Board-Certified Forensic Psy chologistChieL Forensic Psy cliolo^ Serv iceDirector. Forensic Psv chologv Fellow ship Walter Reed Amiv Medical Center(b) (6)(b) (6)"The United Stales tliemselves are essentially the greatest poem.Past and present and fulure are not disjoined but joined."FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYil>02221813From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYSweda, Michael G Dr CIV USA MEDCOM WRAMC>Monday, March 14, 2011 10:34 AMFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)>Benesh, Samantha M MAJ MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC(b) (6)coombs@armycourtmartialdefense.com; Morrow IE,JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)>;;Matthew kemkes (b) (6)Haberiand, John CPT MIL USA (b) (6)>; Carlile, MonicaL.SFC USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA ; Hemphill,Maria R LTC MIL USA MEDCOM BAMC (b) (6)(b) (6)RE: RCM 706-Additional Charges (US v. PFC BM) (UNCLASSIFIED)Classification; UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NONESir:Yes. wc will arrange for an appointment for neurological examination and brain imaging. Could you please provide several dates andtimes tliat PFC Mamiing could be seen ai WRAMC'Also, our forensicreportsarc not put into AHLTA. 1 assmne there would be no objection to theresultsofthe neurologicale.vamination being placed in AHLTA? The brain imaging and neurological ev aluation are strictly medical and not forensic findings.v/r.Micliael Sweda. Ph D . ABPP (Forensic)Board-Certified Forensic PsychologistChief Forensic Psychology Sen iceDirector. Forensic Psychology Fellowsliip Walter Reed Anny Medical Center(b) (6)(b) (6)"The United States themselves arc essentially tiic greatest poem.Past and present and future arc not disjoined but joined."FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02891781From:SenLTo:Cc:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJAMonday,March 14,2011 10:55 AMSweda,MichaelGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMCBenesh,SamanthaMMAJ MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC;coombs@armycourtmartia1defense.com; Morrow 111, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MOWSJA: Matthew kemkes: (b) (6); Haberiand, John CPT MIL USA;C a r i i l e , M o n i c a L S F C USA JFHQNCR/MDW SJA: Hemphill,MariaRLTC MIL USAMEDCOM BAMC; Keyin D Moore@med navy mi1RE: RCM 706-AdditiondCharges(USy PFCBM) (UNCLASSIFIEO)Sir,Please follow a l l normal procedures for capturing medical tests (including inputting theinformation in AHLTA). The only information that needs to be removed is classifiedinformation from the interview, pursuant to the convening authority's order.We can move PFC BM any day that you schedule his appointments, so long as we are given fourduty days notice, to coordinate the move and security. Please let us know which days you planon moving him, and we w i l l schedule.Also, because the board did not meet the suspense to complete the board, please provide arequest to the convening authority to extend the suspense with your best estimate of i t scompletion date. I f possible, please provide this request today so that we can promptly geti t to the convening authority.BreakIn future correspondences, please refer to PFC BM using the accused or an abbreviation, e.g.PFC BM or BM. This request is for security purposes.Thank you.v/nCPT FeinAshden FeinCPT, JAUnclassifiedEmailRCM 706 0135FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221806From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYSweda, Michael G Dr CIV USA MEDCOM WRAMC>Monday, March 14, 2011 1:23 PMFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)l>Benesh, Samantha M MAJ MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC(b) (6)coombs@arniycourtmartialdefense.cora; Morrow IU,JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6);Matthew kemkes ; Carlile, Monica L.SFC USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)l>; Hemphill,Maria R LTC MIL USA MEDCOM BAMC (b) (6)(b) (6)RE: RCM 706-Additional Charges (US v. PFC BM) (UNCLASSIFIED)Classification; UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats; NONESir:If 26 fvfarch is not chosen, we would be avaiWilc 4 April (a Monday), or 9 April (a Satiirday).v/r.Micliael Sweda. Ph.D.. ABPP (Forensic)Board-Certified Forensic PsychologistChief. Forensic Psy chology ServiceDirector. Forensic Psv chologv Fellow ship Walter Reed Armv Medical Center(b) (6)"The United Stales themselves are essentially the greatest poem.Past and present and future are not disjoined but joined."FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221799From:Sent:To:Cc:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYSweda, Michad G Dr CIV USA MEDCOM WRAMC>Monday, March 14, 2011 2:34 PMSweda, Michael G Dr CIV USA MEDCOM WRAMC(b) (6)>; Fdn. Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDWSJA Benesh, Samantha M MAJ MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC(b) (6)>; coombs@armycourtmartialdefense.com; Morrow IB,JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)>;Matthew kemkes (b) (6);Haberiand, John CPT MIL USA ; Cariile, Monica L.SFC USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA ; Hemphill,Maria R LTC MIL USA MEDCOM BAMC (b) (6)>;(b) (6)(b) (6)Subject:RE: RCM 706-Additiond Charges (US v. PFC BM) (UNCLASSIFIED)Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NONESirAnother matter has been called to my attention, and llie 9 April date would be preferred over 4 April,v/r.Micliael Sweda, Ph D.. ABPP (Forensic)Board-Certified Forensic PsychologistCliieL Forensic Psychology ServiceDirccior. Forensic Psv chologv Fellow slup Walter Reed Anny Medicd Center(b) (6)"Tlic United States llicmsciv cs arc essentiallytiicgreatest poem.Past and present and future arc not disjoined but joined."FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221791From:Sent:To:Cc:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYSweda, Michad G Dr CIV USA MEDCOM WRAMC(b) (6)Monday, March 14, 2011 2:50 PMFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)>Benesh, Samantha M MAJ MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC(b) (6)>; coombs@armycourtmartialdefense.com; Morrow III,JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)l>;Matthew kemkes (b) (6); (b) (6)Haberiand, John CPT MIL USA ; Hemphill,(b)(6)Maria R LTC MIL USA MEDCOM BAMC;(b) (6)Subject:RE: RCM 706-Additiond Charges (US v. PFC BM) (UNCLASSIFIED)Classification; UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NONESir:PFC BM lias an MRl scheduled at WR AMC for Wed 23 March at 1330. He w ill be seen by LTC Maigaret Swanberg at tiicNeurology clinic on WD 61 al 11(X) tlial same day.As a point of clarification in temis of tlic next sclicdulcd ev aluation, botii LTC Hempliill and MAJ Benesh are currently schedded lopresent at a training activity on 4 April Tlie activity is only sclieduled to occur once evety three monllis. and vve would like topreserve tlial activity if at all possible. Hence, the 9 April date (a Saturday) is preferablev/r,Micliael Sweda. Ph.D.. ABPP (Forensic)Board-Certified Forensic PsychologistChief Forensic Psy chology Sen iceDirector, Forensic Psv chology Fellowship Walter Reed Army Medical Center(b) (6)"Tlic United States themselves arc essentially the grealcsi poem.Past and present ;md future are nol disjoined bul joined "FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221783From:Sent:To:Cc:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYSweda, Michael G Dr CIV USA MEDCOM WRAMC>Monday, March 14,2011 3:21 PMFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)>Benesh, Samantha M MAJ MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC(b) (6)>; coombs@armycourtmartialdefense.com; Morrow DI,JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA ;Matthew kemkes Thursday,Marchl7,20II7:57AMFein, Ashden CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)OutofOffice:RCM706 AdditiondCharges(USyPFCBM)(UNCLASSIFIED)(b) (6)l>Iwill be out oftiieoffice from 15-21 fvfarch201LFrom15-18Mareh1wiIl have intermittent access totillsemail account. From 1921 Marchlwill not have any access to this email account Ifyourequireimmediate assistance please contactMichael Sweda,Dti^ector, WRAMC Forensic Psychology Fellowship Program, (b) (6)65 v/r MAJ SamantiiaBeneshUnclassifiedEmail RCM 706 0142FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02891730From:SenLTo:Cc:Subject:Attachments:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJASunday, March 20, 2011 12:52 AMSweda,MichaelGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMCBenesh,SamanthaMMAJ MIL USA MEOCOM MAMC;coombs@armycourtmartia1defense.com; Morrowlll,JoDean,CPT USA JFHQNCR/MDWl; Haberiand, John CPT MIL USA;SJA: Matthew kemkes; (b) (6)Cariile,MonicaLSFC USA JFHQNCR/MOW SJA: Hemphill,MariaRLTC MIL USAMEOCOM BAMC: (b) (6)RE: RCM 706^Additiond Charges (USvPFCBM) (UNCLASSIFIED)11Mar-18-SPCMCA Sanity Boatd Extension Approval (ManningB).pdf; 10-Ju105-Origina1Charge Sheet DISMISSED REDACTED (ManningB) pdf;11-Mar-01-AddifionalChatge SheetREDACTED (ManningB) pdfOr. Sweda,Good evening. Attached is the convening authority's approval of yourextensions however note the suspense date is set for the board to becomplete no later than 16 April 2011. Please submit additional requests forextensions, to be considered by the convening authority, i f you need moretime, as 16 April approaches.Also, we are scheduled to for PFC BM to move to WRAMC on 23 March 2011, forhis two appointments: (1) Neurology at 1100 (2) MRl at 1300. We are alsoscheduled for the board to meet at the SCIF in Metro Park (Alexandria) on 9April 2011. Ifyou need to schedule any other tests, please let us knowASAP so we can schedule the movements and security for PFC BM.Also, yesterday the convening authority dismissed the original chargesagainst PFC BM and directed the Article 32 investigating officer to considerthe additional charges. Attached are copies of both charge sheets, eventhough you already received the additional charge sheet from me on 2 March2011. Since the original charges were dismissed, you do not need toconsider them in your evaluation.Thank you. Have a good weekend.y/rCPT feinAshden FeinCPT, JAUnclassifiedEmai1RCM 706 0143FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221775From:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYSweda, Michael G Dr CIV USA MEDCOM WRAMC(b) (6)Sent:To:Cc:Monday, March 21,2011 8:21 AMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)il>Benesh, Samantha M MAJ MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC(b) (6)coombs@armycourtmartialdefense.com; Morrow IE,JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)>;Matthew kemkes (b) (6);(b)(6)Haberiand, John CPT MIL USA ; Hemphill,Maria R LTC MIL USA MEDCOM BAMC (b) (6)Subject:RE: RCM 706.Additional Charges (US v PFC BM) (UNCLASSIFIED)Classification; UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NONESirThank you for the update. We plan on starting at 0900 on Satiirday 9 April for the interview. If you could please forward the address.I would appreciate it.v/r.Micliiiel Sweda. Ph D.. ABPP (Forensic)Board-Certified Forensic PsychologistChief. Forensic Psychology ServiceDirector. Forensic Psychology Fellow ship Walter Reed Anny Medical Center(b) (6)"The United Slates Ihemselves are essentially tiie greatest poem.Past and present and future are not dsjoincd bul joined."FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02891720From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein, Ashden CRT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJAMonday,March 21,2011 8:23 AMSweda,MichadGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMCBenesh,SamanthaMMAJ MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC;coombs@armycourtmartia1defense com; Morrow 111, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDWHaberiand, John CPT MIL USA;SJA: Matthew kemkes; (b) (6)Cariile,MonicaLSFC USA JFHQNCR/MDW SJA; Hemphill,MariaRLTC MIL USAMEOCOM BAMC; (b) (6)RE: RCM 706Additiond Charges (USvPFCBM) (UNCLASSIFIED)Dr. Sweda,Thank you.I w i l l forward the address later in the week,y/rCPT FeinAshden FeinCPT, JAUnclassified EmailRCM 706 0145FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02892107FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFrom:Sent:To:Subject:Fein,Ashden CPTUSA JFHQNCR/MOW SJATuesday,March 22, 2011 12:36 PMMalone, RickyDCOL MIL USA MEOCOM WRAMCRE: Quantico Back up (UNCLASSIFIED)Importance:HighSin,The Marine Corps i s requesting the assistance of additional behavioral health assets t oaugment the brig. I am not sure whether LTC Russell or the female psychologists w i l l f u l f i l lthe b i l l for this request. Oo you have an estimate of when the psychologist w i l l be on-boardready to go, and i f so how frequently w i l l she be able t o go t o the Brig?Thank you.v/rCPT FeinAshden FeinCPT, JAOriginal MessageFrom: Malone, Ricky OCOLMIL USAMEDCOMWRAMC Imailto(b) (6))Sent: Tuesday, MarchlS, 2011 3:26PMTo:Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHONCR/MOWSJA^ Morrow I I I , JoOean,CPT USA JFHONCR/MOW SJASubject: t^uanticoBackup (UNCLASSIFIEO)Classification:Caveats: NONEUNCLASSIFIEOI wanted to make you aware that LTC Robert Russell w i l l be covering the brig whenever I am onleave or TOY, i n case you need t o have him cleared t o see PFC Manning. He has a TS, buttherapy i s completely unclassified anyway (at least u n t i l after his t r i a l ) . I t w i l l probablybe a couple of weeks before he i s credentialed t o see patients out there.Also, I am trying t o make arrangements to have a psychologist see him regularly forpsychotherapy, I ' l l send along her particulars when she's on board.Regards,RickMalone, MO, MPHCOL, MC, SFSPhone(b) (6)Director, Center for Forensic Behavioral Sciences Forensic Psychiatry Consultant t o the ArmySurgeon General USAAMA Aeromedical Psychiatry Consultant(b)(6)Classification:UNCLASSIFIEOo^^,^^^^^^Em^^,RCM 706 0^^6FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02892107FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYCaveats: NONE2Unclassi?ed_EmaiI_RCM_7D6_D146 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221773From:Sent:To:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYMdone, Ricky D COL MIL USA MEDCOM WRAMCThursday,March24,20112:45PMFein, Ashden CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA Thursday,March24, 20113:08 PMFein, Ashden CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA Monday,March 28, 2011 10:01 PMFein, Ashden CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)OutofOffice:QuanticoBackup(UNCLASSIEIED)(b) (6)Iwill be on leave until Moday,April 4th. Ifyou need assistance, please contact our adidnistrative assistant at(b) (6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0154FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02202161From:Sent:To:Cc:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYHaberiand, John CPT MIL USA (b) (6)il>Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:02 AMSweda, Michael G Dr CIV USA MEDCOM WRAMC(b) (6)>; Benesh, SamanthaM MAJ MIL USA MEDCOMMAMC (b) (6); Hemphill, Maria R LTC MIL USA MEDCOMBAMC (b) (6)>Carlile, Monica L. SFC USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA ;Morrow 111, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA; Joyner, Chad SSG MIL USA(b) (6); Williaras, Bruce A ISG MIL USA(b) (6)Subject:R.C.M. 706 interview of PFC M (UNCLASSIFIED)Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: FOUOALCON:The R.CM. 706 inquiry is scheduled to begin at 0900 at the 3"^"^ floor conference room on the Metro Park Facility.The address is the facility is:6359 Walker LaneAlexandria, Virginia 22310There is a parking structure located behind the building. I recommend entering through the side door of the facility (closest tothe parking garage). A security guard will meet you at the side door ofthe facility to let you in and direct you to the elevators totake you to the third floor. A member of the prosecution team will also be there to coordinate any last minute issues. The guardwill be at the side door of the facility between 0830 and 0900.Once you arrive on the third floor, there are signs directing you to the se4curity station where you will receive your temporarybadges and then they will escort you into the conference room where the board will be conducted. I have provided your socialsecurity numbers to the security manager at the facility and she has verified your clearances so there will not be any slowdownin entering the conference room.If anyone has any questions or concerns please let me know and we can address them.Very Respectfully,CPTJohn HaberiandMilitary Oistrict of Washington Legal Spokesman(b) (6)Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: FOUOFOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221752From:Sent:To:Cc:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYSweda, MichadGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMCWednesday,March 30, 201112 39 PMHaberland, John CPT MIL USA ;HemphilL MariaRLTC MIL USAMEDCOM BAMC (b) (6)l>Carlile, MonicaLSFC USAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA(b) (6)>; Fein, Ashden CPT USAJFHQNCR/MDW(b)(6)SJAMonow III, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQNCR/MDW SJA;coorabs@arraycourtmartialdefenseconi; Matthewkemkes(b) (6)(b) (6),Joynei,ChadSSGMILUSA; Williaras, BmceAISG MIL USAR E R C M 706intet^^iewofPFCM(UNCLASSIFlED)Classification; UNCLASSIFIEDCavcalsFOUOSir:Just confirming that tills is 10 st^ut 0900 Salurday9Aprifv/r.Micliael SwedaPliD ABPP (Forensic)Board-Certified Forensic Psy chologistChieL Forensic Psy chology Serv iceDirector. Forensic Psvchologv Fellowslup WalterReed Army Medicd Center(b) (6)(b) (6)"The United States themselv es are essentially the greatest poem.Past and present and fulure arc not disjoined bul joined "Unclassified Email RCM 706 0156FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02202146From:Sent:To:Cc:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYHaberland, John CPT MIL USA (b) (6)>Wednesday, March 30, 2011 12:41 PMSweda, Michael G Dr CIV USA MEDCOM WRAMC; Benesh, Samantiia M MAJ MIL USAMEDCOM MAMC Cariile. Monica L. SFC USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA(b) (6)>; Fdn, Ashden CPT USAJFHQ-NCR/MDWSJA ; Monow III, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ(b)(6)NCR/MDW SJA>;coombs@armycourtmartialdefense.com; Matthew kemkes(b) (6)(b) (6)(b) (6)(b) (6)(b) (6)Subject:Hall Cassius Mr FMMC (FTMYER); Davis, Patsy A Ms CIV USA fNSCOMLease, John V. CIV JFHQ-NCR/MDW PMO>, Joyner, Chad SSG MIL USAWilliams, Bruce A ISG MIL USARE RCM 706 interview of PFC M (UNCLASSIFIED)ClassificationUNCLASSIFIEDCaveatsFOUOALCON:lapologi:^e for my omission earlier. The R.C.M.706 board is scheduled to take place on Saturday,9Apri1 2011 at 0900.Very Respectfully,CPTJohn HaberlandMilitary District of Washington Legal Spokesman(b) (6)FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02907156FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFrom:Sent:To:Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJAThursday.March 31,2011 3:33 PMMalone,RickyDCOL MIL USAMEDCOM WRAMCSubject:ClearancesSir,I assume because you sent me LTC Russell and Or. Yeaw^s SSN, that you recommend they bothhave TS/SCI with read ons? Please verify so we can act. Thank you.v/rCPTFeinAshden FeinCPT, JAUnclassifiedEmailRCM 706 0158FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221751pSent:To:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYMdone, Ricky D COL MIL USA MEDCOM WRAMC(b) (6)>Friday, April 1,2011 9:26 A MFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)RE: Clearances>No. they just need access to see Manning as a patient. Dr Russell as my back-up when I'm out and Dr. Yeaw forp^chotlierapy,doesntrequireaccess to classified infonnationV/R.Rick Malone. MD. MPHCOL. MC. SFSPhone(b) (6)Forensic Psycliialiy Consultant to ilic Army Sui^con GeneralUSAAMA Aeromedical Psychiatry Coiisullanl(b) (6)FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02907160FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFrom:Sent:To:Subject:Thank youFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDWSJAFriday,Apri1 01,201111:10 AM'(b) (6)Re: Clearancessir.Ashden F e i nCPT, JAFOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02231273From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:Signed 8 y :FOROFFICIALUSEONLYRains, L a r r y E M r C I V USA OCS G-2 (b) (6)Safurday,Apri1 02, 2011 10:26 AMHemphill,MariaRLTC MIL USA MEDCOM BAMC; (b) (6)Fein,Ashden C P T U S A J F H Q N C R / M D W SJA; Cariile, MonicaL. SFC USAJFHQNCR/MDWSJA(U) SSBI Complete(b) (6)C l a s s i f i c a t i o n : UNCLASSIFIEO//FOR OFFICIALUSE ONLYMaria,Your SSBI was f a v o r a b l y a d j u d i c a t e d (no l o n g e r an I n t e r i m S C I ) . Your n e x tPR i s due f i v e y e a r s f r o m y o u r c l o s e d i n v e s t i g a t i o n d a t e (2011 03 2 3 ) .E x c e r p t f r o m JPAS:HEMPHILL, MARLARAEPSI A d j u d i c a t i o n o f SSBIOPM, O p e n e d 2 0 1 1 0 1 2 8 , C l o s e d 2 0 1 1 0 3 2 3 ,d e t e r m i n e d E l i g i b i l i t y o f SCI0 C I 0 6 / 4 o n 2011 03 31 ArmyCCF.Best r e g a r d s ,LarryL a r r y RainsS e c u r i t y Manager/SSRHOOA, OOCS, G 21000 Army PentagonWashington O C 2 0 3 1 0 1 0 0 0(b)(6)C l a s s i f i c a t i o n : UNCLASSIFIEO//FOR OFFICIALUSE ONLYUnclassified Email RCM 706 0161FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02891942From:SenLTo:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYSubject:Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQNCR/MDWSJAFriday, April 08, 2011 7:08 AMSweda,MichaelGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMC: Benesh,SamanthaMMAJ MIL USAMEOCOM MAMC: Hemphill,MariaRLTC MIL USA MEDCOM BAMCHaberland,John CPT MIL USA; Cariile,MonicaL. SFC USAJFHQNCF^MOW SJA; Monow111,JoDean,CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDWSJA; (b) (6);Matthew kemkes: (b) (6); HallCassius Mr FMMC (FTMYER)RE:RCM 706inteiviewofPFCM(UNCLASSIF1EO)Importance:HighCc:Or. Sweda,Good morning. In light of the looming Furlough, could you please let me know whether theBoard w i l l s t i l l be available tomorrow to conduct i t s interview? We are currently verifyingwith the support staff involved with movement, security, and f a c i l i t i e s , to ensure there areno shutdowns planned.Also, SFC Monica Carlile w i l l be at the Metro Park f a c i l i t y to greet theto the conference room. I f you have any issues tomorrow, please call my(b) (6)^Iso note that you w i l l not be able to bring cell phones intoso please have my number available hard-copy. Cell phones may be storedsecurity check point.Board and escort youblackberry at(b) (6)the conference room^outside of theAfter your confirmation back to me about tomorrow, I plan on sending a final confirmation toyou no later than 1500 today.Thank you.v/rCPT FeinAshden FeinCPT, JAUnclassified Email RCM 706 0162FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221748From:Sent:To:Cc:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYHemphill, Maria R LTC MIL USA MEDCOM BAMC (b) (6)>Friday, April 8, 2011 1 13 PMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)>,Sweda, Michael G Dr CIV USA MEDCOM WRAMC(b) (6)Benesh, Samantha M MAJ MIL USAMEDCOM MAMC (b) (6)Haberiand, John CPT MIL USA (b) (6)l>; Cariile, Monica L.SFC USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)>; Monowtil, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA(b) (6); coombs@armycourtmartialdefense.com;Matthew kemkes (b) (6)Hall Cassius Mr FMMC (FTMYER)(b) (6)Subject:RE R.C M 706 interview of PFC M (UNCLASSIFIED)CPTFeinIplan to be there. DrSweda and MAJ Benesh are ataconference today butlwiti let them know about your message and ask them toreplyLTC HemphillFOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221743From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:Signed By:Classification:Caveats: FOUOFOROFFICIALUSEONLYBenesh,SamanthaMMAJ MIL USA MEOCOM MAMC (b) (6)Friday, April 08, 2011 2;11PMHemphill,MarlaRLTC MIL USA MEDCOM BAMC; Fein,Ashden CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA; Sweda,MichadGOtCIVUSA MEOCOM WF^MCHaberiand,John CPTMIL USA: Carlile,MonicaL. SFC USAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA; Monow111, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA; coombs@armycourtmartia1defense.com;Matthewkemkes:(b) (6)HallCassius Mr FMMC (FTMYER)R E : R C M 706infetviewofPFCM(UNCLASS1FIED)BENESHSAMANTHAMAR1E 1272647034UNCLASSIFIEOCPT Fein,Per guidance ft^om our Oepartment Chief, COL Ounivin, we are good t o go forthe intet^view tomorrow regardless of whethet^ a furlough i s i n effect. Or.Sweda and I w i l l be there promptly at 0900, unless we receive other guidancefrom you this afternoon by 1600. Neither Or. Sweda nor I w i l l have accessto our email accounts after 1600. I f you need t o reach us for any reason,please feel free t o contact me at my c e l l phone number below.v/r,Samantha M. BeneshMAJ, MS, USAForensic Psychology FellowWalter Reed Army Medical Center(b) (6)(b) (6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0164FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02891923From:SenLTo:Cc:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJAFriday,April08, 2011 2:59 PMBenesh,SamanthaMMAJ MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC; Hemphill,MariaRLTC MIL USAMEOCOM BAMC; Sweda,MichadGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMCHaberiand,John CPT MIL USA; Cariile,MonicaLSFC USAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA; Monow111,JoDean,CPT USA JFHQ-NCF^MDWSJA:coombs@annycourtmartialdefensecom;Matthew kemkes: (b) (6)HallCassiusMr FMMC (FTMYER)RE:RCM 706interviewofPFCM(UNCLASS1F1EO)Board Members,We at^e s t i l l on for tomot^t^ow, despite the furlough. The building w i l l beopen and SFC Carlile w i l l meet you at the front doot^ at 0900. Thank you.v/rCPTFeinAshden FeinCPT, JAUnclassifiedEmail RCM 706 0165FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221738From:SenLTo:Subject:Signed By:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYBenesh,SamanthaMMAJ MIL USA MEOCOM MAMC (b) (6)Friday.April 08, 2011 3:49 RMFein,/^hden CRT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJAR E ; R C M 706interviewofPFCM(UNCLASS1F1EO)BENESHSAMANTHAMAR1E 1272647034Classification: UNCLASSIFIEOCaveats: FOUORoger.Thanks for the coordination.UnclassifiedEmailRCM 706 0166FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02884583FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFrom:SenLTo:Cc:(b) (6)(b) (6)Subject:coombs@armycourtmartia1defense.com; Mon^ow 111, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MOWSJA: Matthew kemkes; (b) (6)USvPFC BMUpdafeImportance:HighFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJAFriday,Apri115, 2011 7:59 AMOr. Sweda,Good morning. The purpose of this update i s determine whether the 706 boardw i l l be able to meet i t s suspense with completing the report by tomorrow (16April 2011). I f not, please send an extension request with a j u s t i f i c a t i o n .Also, is there any more testing or interviews that you need the Governmentto organize for the board?Thank you.v/rCPT FeinAshden FeinCPT, JAUnclassified Email RCM 706 0167FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221737From:Sent:To:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYBenesh, SamanthaMMAJMIL USAMEDCOMMAMCIwillbeoutoftiieofficefrom 12-14 April 2011. Iwiti not have access to this email account duringthistimeperiod. Ifyou requireimmediate assistance please contact Michael Sweda, Director.WRAMC Forensic Psychology Fellowship Program(b) (6)v/r MAJ Samantha BeneshUnclassified Email RCM 706 0168FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221735From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYSweda, Michael G Dr CIV USA MEDCOM WRAMCFriday, April 15, 2011 9:07 AMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)l>(b) (6); Benesh, Samantiia M MAJ MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC(b) (6); coombs@armycourtraartialdefense.com; Morrow III,JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6),(b)(6)Matthew kemkes <>; Bouchard, Paul CPTUSCENTCOM>;USF-1 USCENTCOM-TDS/FICI-JA-TBO (b) (6)Haberiand, John CPT MIL USA (b) (6)>RE: US v. PFC BM-Update (UNCLASSIFIED)Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveatsNONESinIjust spoke withall members oftiie 706 Board. Weanticipate completing thereportthis evening, perhaps late, but this eveningv/r.Michael Sweda. PIiD.ABPP (Forensic)Board-Certified Forensic Psy chologistChief Forensic Psy chology Serv iceDirector. Forensic Psvchologv Fellowship Walter Reed AmivMedical Center(b) (6)(b) (6)"The United Stales Ihemselves are essentially the greatest poem.P^isl and present and future are not disjoined but joined."FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02884576FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFrom:SenLTo:Cc:(b) (6)(b) (6)Subject:'coombs@armycourtmartiaklefense.com'; Morrow 111, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MOWSJA: Matthewkemkes: Bouchard,Paul CPT USCENTCOM USFIUSCENTCOMTDS/FICIJA-TBO:'(b) (6)'R e U S v P F C BMUpdafe (UNCLASSIFIED)Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJAFriday, April 15, 20119:21 AMSir,Thank you. I t is not our intent to rush or move the board to be inaccurate^ howevet^ i f t h esuspense can be met then i t should. I f you can not finish by tomorrow, please send an emailrequest and we w i l l forward to the convening authority.Ashden FeinCPT, JAUnclassified Email RCM 706 0170FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221732FOROFFICIALUSEONLYSweda,MichadGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMCSent:Friday,April 15,2011 9:42 AMTo:Fein, Ashden CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA Benesh, SamanthaMMAJ MIL USA MEDCOMM/^CCc:raarl (b) (6)(b)(6)<>;coombs@armycourtmartialdefense com; Morrow IB,JoDean, CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)>;>; Bouchard, Paul CPTUSCENTCOMMatthew kemkes Subject:RE: USvPFC BMUpdate(UNCLASSlFIED)From:ClassificationUNCLASSIFIEDCaveatsNONESir:Weare ruslied One ofthe board members was out tliree daystliis week. One board memberwill perhaps have just enoughtimetoreviewthe longreport10 meet Ihe suspense tod^iy Ifadditioiialtimeispossiblelwoddrespeclfullyreqtiestanadditioii^tivveek Theboard li^is limited availability to meet togetlier due to leave and conflicting schedules. 98^^oftiie longreportlias been finali:^d. butwe shottid Iiave, idedly . moretimeto meet and discuss the 6.1II report.Ivvitisendafonndrequestforaone-vveek extension, butwiticoidnue pressing forward in case this is not approved.v/r.Micliael Sweda. Ph D . ABPP (Forensic)Board-Certified Forensic Psy chologistChieL Forensic Psy chology Serv iceDirector.ForensicPsycliologyFellowship Walter Reed Armv Medical Center(b) (6)"The United Stateslhcmselves are essentially the greatest poem.Past and present and future are not disioined but joined."^^^^^^,^Em^^,RCM7^o^7^FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221728From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:Attach:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYSweda, MichadGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMC(b) (6)Friday,Aprti 15,2011 9 59 AMFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6); Benesh, SamanthaMMAJ MIL USA MEDCOMMAMC; Bouchard, Paul CPTUSCENTCOMUSFlUSCENTCOMTDS/FIClJATBOREUSyPFCBMUpdate(UNCLASSlFlED)Manning extension request 22 April pdfClassification; UNCLASSIFIEDCaveatsNONEALCON:Ple^ise see extensionrequest(att^iched).v/r.Micliael Sweda. PhD.ABPP (Forensic)Board-Certified Forensic Psy chologistChieL Forensic Psy chology Serv iceDirector. Forensic Psv chologv Fellow sliip Walter Reed Army f v ^ i c d Center(b) (6)"The United States Ihemselves are essentially the greatest poem.Past and present and future arc not disjoined but joined "Unclassified Email RCM 706 0172FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02884578From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:Attachments:Or.FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein, Ashden CRT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJAFriday, April 15, 2011 5:30 RMSweda,MichaelGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMC(b) (6); Benesh,SamanthaMMAJ MIL USA MEOCOM MAMC;coombs@armycourtmartia1defense.com; Morrow 111, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDWSJA: Matthewkemkes; Bouchard,Pad CPT USCENTCOM USFIUSCENTCOMTDS/FICIJATBO; Habertand,John CPT MIL USARE: USvPFC BMUpdafe (UNCLASSIFIED)I1-Apr-16-SPCMCA RCM 706 Extension Approval (ManningB).pdfSweda,Attached is the SPCMCA's approval of your request,v/rCPT FeinAshden FeinCPT, JAUnclassified Email RCM 706 0173FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221727From:Sent:To:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYSweda,MichadGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMCL>Friday,April 15,20115:31PMFein, Ashden CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)OufofOffice: USvPFC BMUpdate(UNCLASSIEIED)(b) (6)>Iain scheduled to be out oftiieoffice18tiuough 19 Apriflmay be reached for urgent or other matiers via ceti phone (b) (6)Or, contactmy Deputy ChiefDrPaul Montalbano at (b) (6)(b)(6)Unclassified Email RCM 706 0174FOROFFICIALUSEONLY-02221726FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYp^^^,Benesh, Samantha M MAJ MIL USA MEDCOM MAMCI will be out oftiieoffice from 16-20 April 2011. I will not liave access to this email account during this time period. Ifyou requueimmediate assistance please (b) (6)v/r MAJ Samantha BeneshUn.assi«.d_Emai,_RCM.706.0,75,.....FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221723From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYSweda, Michael G Dr CIV USA MEDCOM WRAMCSaturday, April 16, 2011 8:30 /IMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)>(b) (6)Benesh, Samantha M MAJ MIL USA MEDCOM MAMC(b) (6)>; coombs@armycourtmartialdefense.cora; Morrow IB,JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)>;Matthew kemkes (b) (6)Bouchard, Paul CPT USCENTCOMUSF-I USCENTCOM-TDS/FICI-JA-TBO (b) (6);(b)(6)Haberland, John CPT MIL USA>RE: US v. PFC BM-Update (UNCLASSIFIED)Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NONESir:nmnk you veiy mtKh. This vvill pennit adequate time for full discussion.Micliael SwedaFOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02907517FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein,Ashden CPT USAJFHQNCF^MDW SJATuesday,Apri1 19, 2011 5:03 PMFrom:Sent:To:Subject:(b) (6)Importance:HighChafTonightSirI f you are available to chat, please call me at (b) (6)to chat tonight, i f possible. Thank you. v/r CPT FeinAshden FeinCPT, JAUnclassified Email RCM 706 0177FOROFFICIALUSEONLY. We need02221722FOROFFICIAL USE ONLYMalone, Ricky D COL MIL USA MEDCOM WRAMC>Tuesday, April 19, 201 1 5:05 PMFdn, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (b) (6)(6)Re: Chat Tonight(b) (6)Sent:To:Subject:1 can call now, I'm on the train if tkit's OK.Rick Malone. MD. MPHCOL. MC. SFS(b) (6)Forensic Psychiatry Consuluuit to the Amiy Surgeon GeneralUSAAMA Aeromedical Psy chiatry Coiisullanl(b) (6)FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY>02907516FOROFFICIAL USE ONLYFrom:Sent:To:Subject:Please call sir.Fein, /Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MOW SJATuesday, April 19, 2011 5:06 PMMalone, Ricky 0 COL MIL USA MEDCOM WRAMCRE: Chat TonightThanks. 202450 8230Ashden FeinCPT, JAFOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221721From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYSweda, MichadGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMCFriday,April 22, 2011 9:39 AMFein, Ashden CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)>MorrowIILJoDean, CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA(b) (6)>; Carlile, Monica SFC MIL USA OTJAGRE Eiicrypfed Eraail (UNCLASSIFIED);Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveatsNONESirs;Tliis(us.amiy.mil) also won't vvori^. We are stillfinali,^iiigthereportsbutwiti liave by COB lod^iy. You can sendsomeone over, orlcould deliver to Ihe Pentagon Icnjoy getting out ofthe office vvlicnican and it is on the way home.One ofourboad members is in Te.^s Ijust spoke to her and we anticip^itefinali^ition of lliereportby approximately Noon localtimeOnce again,tiiankyouforyourcontinued patience.Michael Sweda^^^a^^^^adEm^^,RCM 706 0^6^FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02902749From:SenLTo:SubjecLFOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDWSJAFriday,Apri122, 2011 9:50 AMSweda,MichadGOrCIVUSA MEOCOM WF^MC: Morrow 111,JoDean,CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDWSJARE: Encrypted Email (UNCLASSIFIED)Sir,We can either pick i t up or you can come on over. Whatever is the easiestfor you. We actually work at Ft McNair at the Waterfront near nationalsstadium. Unlimited parking and near the metro.Please let us know what you prefer. Thanks.y/rCPT FeinAshden FeinCPT, JAUnclassified Email RCM 706 0183FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02221716From:Sent:To:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYSweda, Michael G Dr CIV USA MEDCOM WRAMC>Friday, April 22, 2011 9:52 A MFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)Morrow 111, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA(b) (6)>RE: Encrypted Email (UNCLASSIFIED)(b) (6)>;Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCav eats: NONECPTFein:Ev en better at Fl. McNair I w ould be by aboul 1600. perliaps just a bit eariier if llial is OK. Just tell me your olfice locationMicliael SwedaFOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02902744FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYFrom:SenLTo:Fein, Ashden CRT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJAFriday, Apri122, 2011 9:55 AMSweda,MichadGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMC:NCR/MDW SJASubject:RE: Encrypted Email (UNCLASSIFIED)Monow 111,JoDean,CPTUSAJFHQ-Sir,We are in building 32. When you drive in the main gate off 4th street, ourbuilding is directly to the right of the gate. In fact, when you drive down4th street our office and building is directly in front of you. When youenter the building (OSJA and PAO) go through the double doors on the f i r s tfloor and turn left. We are at the end of the hall. You cannot miss usIThank you.v/t^CPTFeinAshden FeinCPT, JAFOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02221713FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYFrom:Sent:To:Subject:Sweda,MichadGDrCIVUSAMEDCOMWRAMC>Friday,April 22, 20119:56 AMFein, Ashden CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA (b) (6)RE: Encrypted Eraail (UNCLASSIFIED)(b) (6)Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats; NONESec vou around 1600.FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY;02910833From:SenLTo:Cc:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein,/^hden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJAFriday,Apri122, 2011 2:36 RM(b) (6)Subject:coombs@armycourtmartialdefense.com; Morrow til, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW(6)(6)SJA: Matthewkemkes:(b)(b)706Importance:HighOr. Sweda,Thank you for the phone call. During the call, you expressed some confusionon which questions in the convening authority's order that the board neededto answer. You specifically pointed out that the questions asked did notidentically match the questions listed in RCM 706(c)(2)(A)-(O).The Government's interpretation of the convening authority's order is thatthe board is required to give the ultimate answer to the questions posed, in7(a)-(k) (including the subparagraphs) to the Government.Recognizing your concern that the questions are not the exact form of thequestions in the RCM (although they are substantively the same), werecommend you answer the ultimate questions ordered by the conveningauthority. I f you feel that you s t i l l need to answer the ultimate questionsfrom posed in the RCM, then the government recommends you answer thosequestions as well, absent an objection by the defense (who is CCed).As a reminder- please do not provide the government counsel anymore than theanswers to the ultimate questions.v/rCPT FeinAshden FeinCPT, J^UnclassifiedEmail RCM 706 0187FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02916488From:SenLTo:Cc:Subject:Attachments:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJAWednesday,Augusf 03, 2011 5:31 RM(b) (6)Monow III,JoDean,CRT USAJFHQNCR/MDWUSvPFCBMOr Grieger Request pdf; CapL MooreEmai1.pdfSJASi^,I hope a l l is well. Apparently Capt Moore is no longer available to serve asthe defense forensic psychiatrist in our case (see attached emails). Oo youhave any recommendations on another replacement that should be in the localarea and willing to travel to FTLVN periodically that the government may useto appoint?Thank you.y/rAshdenUnclassifiedEmail RCM 706 0188FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02217099FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYFrom:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:Malone, Ricky 0 COL MIL USA MEDCOM WRAMC (b) (6)Thursday, August 04, 2011 1:04 PMFein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MOW SJAMonow 111, JoDean, CPT USA JFHQ-NCR/MDW SJARE: US v. PFC BM (UNCLASSIFIED)Classification: UNCLASSIFIEDCaveats: NONEI'm checking, I ' l l let you know.FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYI(b)(6)02915057From:SenLTo:Cc:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFein, Ashden CPT USAJFHQNCR/MDW SJAThursday, August 04, 2011 1:32 RMMalone, RickyDCOL MIL USA MEOCOM WRAMCMonow 111,JoDean,CPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDW SJARE: U S v P F C B M (UNCLASSIFIED)Thank you s i r .Unclassified Email RCM 706 0190FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02217097FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFrom:SenLTo:Cc:SubjecLMalone, RickyDCOL MIL USA MEDCOM WRAMC (b) (6)Thursday,August04,2011 2:11 RMFein, Ashden CRT USA JFHQ NCR/MOW SJAMorrow 111,JoDean,CPT USAJFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA;OLModfon;Modfon,OavldLLCDRNNMCRE: U S v P F C B M (UNCLASSIFIED)Classification: UNCLASSIFI20Caveats: NONFLCOR Moulton, whom I had originally referred before CAPT Moore becameinvolved, is s t i l l available. I have cc'd his commercial and Navy emailsabove, and he said you may also reach him on his personal cell, (b) (6)1.FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02217092From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:Attach:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYMoulton,DavidE LCDR NNMCThursday. Augusf 4, 2011 2:49 PMMalone, RickyDCOL MIL USAMEDCOMWRAMC(b) (6)>; Fein, Ashden CPTUSAJEHQNCR/MDWSJA,D L Moulton (b) (6)REUSvPFCBM(UNCLASSti^IED)MoulfonNavyCV.pdfCPTFeinIam available and eager to ^issisl MyCVisattaclied.v/rLCDRModlonUnclassified Email RCM 706 0192FOROFFICIALUSEONLY02915054FOROFFICIALUSEONLYFrom:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:Fein, Ashden CPT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJAThursday,Augusf 04, 2011 2:55 RMMalone,RickyDCOL MIL USA MEOCOM WRAMCMorrow 111,JoDean,CPTUSAJFHQ-NCR/MDW SJA; D.LModfon;Modfon,OavldLLCDRNNMCRE: U S v P F C B M (UNCLASSIFIED)Thank you s i r .FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02928044From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLYFein, Ashden CRT USA JFHQ NCR/MDW SJAMonday,Augusf22, 2011 6:25 RMMalone,RickyDCOL MIL USA MEDCOM WRAMCR a r r a , J a i r o A W O I USAJFHQNCR/MDW SJA; O v e r g a a r d , A n g d M C P T USAJFHQNCR/MDW SJALCDR MoultonSit^,Good evening. Could you please provide us good POC information for LCDRMoulton and/or his Oefense Travel System (OTS) POC? We are trying toschedule his travel for our big case and cannot get a hold of him or the POChe provided. Thank you.y/rCPT FeinUnclassified Email RCM 706 0194FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY02217081From:SenLTo:Cc:Subject:FOROFFICIALUSEONLYMalone,RickyO.[R(b) (6)jMonday,Augusf22, 2011 8:07 RMFein, Ashden CRT USA JFHQNCR/MDW SJA; Malone, RickyDCOL MIL USA MEOCOMWRAMCParra,JairoAWOI USAJFHQNCR/MDWSJA; OvergaanJ, AngdMCPTUSAJFHQNCR/MDWSJA; Williams, ShaunfeyOCIVWRAMCRE: LCDR MoultonHe doesn't mind i f you use h i s personal c e l l number or email,(b) (6)(b) (6), (b) (6)As we have not yet made the t r a n s i t i o n t o Bethesda, I am not sure who h i sOTS POC i s . A f t e r the move i t w i l l be our Admin Asst, Ms. W i l l i a m s , c c ' dabove, phone (b) (6). She can a s s i s t you w i t h contacting the r i g h tperson i n the meantime as she w i l l be making contact soon anyway.Regards,RickMalone, MO, MPHCOL, MC, SFS(b) (6)Director, Center f o r Forensic Behavioral SciencesForensic Psychiatry Consultant to the Army Surgeon GeneralUSAAMA Aeromedical Psychiatry Consultant(b) (6)UnclassifiedEmail RCM 706 0195FOROFFICIALUSEONLY

e-Highlighter

Click to send permalink to address bar, or right-click to copy permalink.

Un-highlight all Un-highlight selectionu Highlight selectionh